Burgess N S
Center for Exercise Science and Cardiovascular Research, Northeastern Illinois University, Chicago 60625.
J Am Diet Assoc. 1991 Apr;91(4):430-4.
Very-low-calorie diets (VLCDs) provide a rapid decrease in total body weight, but limited data are available regarding the extent of fat loss and whether body fat distribution is altered. The purpose of this study was to investigate body composition, body fat distribution, and resting metabolic rate in obese men and women and to compare bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) with hydrodensitometry before and after 12 weeks of treatment in a VLCD program. Body composition was assessed by hydrodensitometry and BIA. Circumference measures were used to determine waist:hip and waist:thigh ratios. Seventeen subjects lost a mean of 24.2 kg. A mean of 75.5% of the weight loss was adipose tissue as measured by hydrodensitometry. BIA underestimated body fat percentage compared with hydrodensitometry in this obese population. Waist:hip and waist:thigh ratios showed a small but significant decrease, implying a decreased risk for diabetes and cardiovascular disease after weight loss. Resting metabolic rate, as measured by oxygen consumption, dropped 23.8% during the 12 weeks of the VLCD. The findings indicate that a VLCD can provide a rapid weight loss of more than 75% fat and a concomitant decrease in waist:hip and waist:thigh ratios. The findings also indicate that BIA may not be a useful tool in assessing fat loss in obese subjects. Finally, it appears that the decrease in resting metabolic rate that occurs during treatment with VLCD does not correlate with changes in lean body mass.
极低热量饮食(VLCDs)能使总体重迅速下降,但关于脂肪减少的程度以及体脂分布是否改变的数据有限。本研究的目的是调查肥胖男性和女性的身体成分、体脂分布及静息代谢率,并在VLCD项目治疗12周前后,比较生物电阻抗分析(BIA)与水下密度测量法。身体成分通过水下密度测量法和BIA进行评估。采用围度测量来确定腰臀比和腰大腿比。17名受试者平均减重24.2千克。通过水下密度测量法测得,平均75.5%的体重减轻是脂肪组织。在这个肥胖人群中,与水下密度测量法相比,BIA低估了体脂百分比。腰臀比和腰大腿比有小幅但显著的下降,这意味着减重后糖尿病和心血管疾病的风险降低。通过耗氧量测量的静息代谢率在VLCD的12周治疗期间下降了23.8%。研究结果表明,VLCD能使体重迅速减轻,其中超过75%为脂肪,并同时降低腰臀比和腰大腿比。研究结果还表明,BIA在评估肥胖受试者的脂肪减少情况时可能不是一个有用的工具。最后,在VLCD治疗期间发生的静息代谢率下降似乎与去脂体重的变化无关。