O'Dougherty Maureen, Arikawa Andrea, Kaufman Beth C, Kurzer Mindy S, Schmitz Kathryn H
University of Minnesota, Food Science and Nutrition, St. Paul, Minnesota, USA.
Women Health. 2009 Dec;49(8):642-61. doi: 10.1080/03630240903496150.
It is important to know how physical activity is incorporated in women's lives to assess ways they can feasibly attain and maintain lifelong healthy practices. This study aimed to determine whether patterns of activity differed among young women whose physical activity met nationally recommended levels from those who did not. The sample was 42 women (aged 18-30 years) who had completed an exercise intervention (22 from the exercise group, 20 from the control group). Participants recorded pedometer steps and physical activities in diaries including form, duration and perceived exertion during 12 randomly assigned weeks over 26 weeks. We divided the sample into quartiles of moderate to vigorous physical activity to examine the composition of physical activities per quartile. Walking and shopping comprised the majority of physical activity in the lowest quartile of moderate to vigorous physical activity. In the second and third quartiles, walking and household/childcare together comprised more than two-thirds of all activities. Only in the highest quartile was cardio activity (not including walking, shopping and household/childcare) the largest proportion of activity; this category stood alone as varying significantly across quartiles of moderate to vigorous physical activity (p < 0.005). Among these young adult women, self-reported "lifestyle" physical activity was not sufficient to meet recommended levels of moderate to vigorous physical activity. The one-quarter who met recommended levels of moderate to vigorous physical activity did so largely through purposeful physical activities directly associated with exercise. Further research is needed to refine means of more fully measuring physical activities that women frequently perform, with particular attention to household work, childcare and shopping and to differing combinations of activities and levels of exertion by which diverse women can meet the recommended levels. The findings of this small scale study reinforce the ongoing benefit of recommending structured, planned physical activity at moderate and vigorous levels of intensity to young, healthy women to ensure they obtain the health benefits.
了解体育活动如何融入女性生活对于评估她们切实可行地实现并维持终身健康习惯的方式非常重要。本研究旨在确定达到国家推荐体育活动水平的年轻女性与未达到该水平的年轻女性之间的活动模式是否存在差异。样本为42名女性(年龄在18至30岁之间),她们完成了一项运动干预(运动组22人,对照组20人)。参与者在26周内随机分配的12周时间里,通过日记记录计步器步数和体育活动,包括形式、持续时间和感知运动强度。我们将样本分为中度至剧烈体育活动的四分位数,以检查每个四分位数的体育活动组成。在中度至剧烈体育活动最低的四分位数中,步行和购物占体育活动的大部分。在第二和第三个四分位数中,步行和家务/育儿活动加起来占所有活动的三分之二以上。只有在最高的四分位数中,有氧运动(不包括步行、购物和家务/育儿)才是活动的最大比例;这一类别在中度至剧烈体育活动的四分位数中单独存在,差异显著(p < 0.005)。在这些年轻成年女性中,自我报告的“生活方式”体育活动不足以达到推荐的中度至剧烈体育活动水平。达到中度至剧烈体育活动推荐水平的四分之一人群主要是通过与锻炼直接相关的有目的体育活动来实现的。需要进一步研究以完善更全面测量女性经常进行的体育活动的方法,尤其要关注家务劳动、育儿和购物,以及不同女性通过不同活动组合和运动强度达到推荐水平的情况。这项小规模研究的结果强化了向年轻健康女性推荐中等强度和剧烈强度的结构化、计划性体育活动以确保她们获得健康益处的持续好处。