Tovar J A, Izquierdo M A, Eizaguirre I
Universidad del Pais Vasco, Hospital N.S. de Aranzazu, San Sebastián, Spain.
J Pediatr Surg. 1991 Feb;26(2):163-7. doi: 10.1016/0022-3468(91)90899-5.
This investigation aims at providing simpler methods for reading esophageal extended pH-metering tracings. Because the currently used parameters only quantify frequency and duration of acid exposure, we have measured the area between the pH curve and the pH 4 line (area under curve [AUC]) in an attempt to include in the evaluation the severity of acid exposure as well. We compared 20 control and 63 children with gastroesophageal reflux (GER). Extended pH metering curves were read according to currently accepted methods. In addition, we measured planimetrically total 24-hour AUC, AUC during daytime, AUC during sleep time, and total AUC excluding 2-hour postprandial periods. In spite of the very significant differences found between means of controls and GER patients for all variables considered, values overlapped widely. Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) analysis indicated the best threshold values for differentiation of controls and GER patients and tested the diagnostic efficiency for each variable. We found that 24-hour AUC was the best comprehensive value (sensitivity = 1, specificity = 1) and that there was probably no use for fractional evaluation during selected periods of time. The optimum 24-hour AUC threshold value in the present conditions of measurement (paper speed, 0.25 cm/min; 1 pH unit, 2.5 cm) was 20 cm2. In order to facilitate comparison we propose using a pH-surface unit (pHSU) equal to recording speed (in cm/min) multiplied by vertical shift per 1 pH unit (in centimeters) (in this case, 0.25 x 2.5 = 0.625 cm2). A threshold value of 20 cm2 thus becomes 32 pHSU. A similar transformation will be adequate for any other recording conditions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
本研究旨在提供更简便的方法来解读食管延长pH监测描记图。由于目前使用的参数仅对酸暴露的频率和持续时间进行量化,我们测量了pH曲线与pH 4线之间的面积(曲线下面积[AUC]),试图在评估中纳入酸暴露的严重程度。我们比较了20名对照儿童和63名胃食管反流(GER)儿童。延长pH监测曲线按照目前公认的方法进行解读。此外,我们通过平面测量法测定了24小时总AUC、白天AUC、睡眠时间AUC以及排除餐后2小时的总AUC。尽管在所有考虑的变量方面,对照儿童和GER患者的均值之间存在非常显著的差异,但数值有广泛的重叠。受试者操作特征(ROC)分析确定了区分对照儿童和GER患者的最佳阈值,并测试了每个变量的诊断效率。我们发现24小时AUC是最佳的综合值(敏感性 = 1,特异性 = 1),并且在特定时间段进行分数评估可能没有用处。在当前测量条件下(纸速,0.25 cm/分钟;1个pH单位,2.5 cm),最佳的24小时AUC阈值为20 cm²。为便于比较,我们建议使用一个pH面积单位(pHSU),其等于记录速度(以cm/分钟为单位)乘以每1个pH单位的垂直位移(以厘米为单位)(在这种情况下,0.25×2.5 = 0.625 cm²)。因此,20 cm²的阈值变为32 pHSU。对于任何其他记录条件,类似的转换都是合适的。(摘要截短于250字)