Wiedermann B L, Schwartz R H, McCoy P
Department of Infectious Diseases, George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Washington, D.C. 20010.
J Am Board Fam Pract. 1991 Mar-Apr;4(2):79-82.
We evaluated 2401 patients with suspected streptococcal pharyngitis with the Culturette 10-minute Group A Strep ID test during a 6-month period in order to determine its suitability for rapid diagnosis in a busy private office practice. Duplicate throat swabs were obtained for each child, and latex agglutination was performed within 15 minutes. In children with negative latex agglutination results, the second swab was cultured. All latex agglutination results were available within 20 minutes of collection, while the patients waited in the office. Seven hundred thirty-eight specimens were positive by latex agglutination. Seventy-eight of the 1663 latex negative specimens contained group A streptococci on culture (sensitivity 90 percent). Approximately 60 percent of these latex-negative, culture-positive specimens demonstrated 3(+)-4+ growth in culture, unlike previous studies ascribing false-negative latex results to low colony count specimens. Fifty percent of bacitracin-susceptible streptococci tested were not group A, indicating a relatively high occurrence of nongroup A beta-hemolytic streptococcal carriage in this patient population. The use of latex agglutination for detection of group A streptococcal pharyngitis was well-suited to our office practice, even during an extremely busy winter season. Although this assay appears to have a relatively high sensitivity, it is still prudent to culture latex-negative swabs to exclude group A streptococcal infection. The significance of nongroup A beta-hemolytic streptococci in our patient population was unclear. Further refinements are necessary.
在6个月的时间里,我们使用Culturette 10分钟A组链球菌鉴定试验对2401例疑似链球菌性咽炎的患者进行了评估,以确定该试验在繁忙的私人诊所进行快速诊断的适用性。为每个儿童采集了两份咽喉拭子,并在15分钟内进行乳胶凝集试验。乳胶凝集试验结果为阴性的儿童,其第二份拭子进行培养。所有乳胶凝集试验结果在采集后20分钟内即可获得,此时患者在办公室等待。乳胶凝集试验有738份标本呈阳性。1663份乳胶试验阴性的标本中,有78份在培养时发现含有A组链球菌(敏感性为90%)。与之前将乳胶试验假阴性结果归因于菌落数低的标本的研究不同,这些乳胶试验阴性但培养阳性的标本中约60%在培养时显示3(+)-4+生长。所检测的对杆菌肽敏感的链球菌中有50%不是A组,这表明该患者群体中非A组β溶血性链球菌携带的发生率相对较高。即使在极其繁忙的冬季,使用乳胶凝集试验检测A组链球菌性咽炎也非常适合我们的诊所业务。尽管该检测方法似乎具有相对较高的敏感性,但对乳胶试验阴性的拭子进行培养以排除A组链球菌感染仍然是谨慎的做法。我们患者群体中非A组β溶血性链球菌的意义尚不清楚,还需要进一步完善。