Zollinger Paul E, Kreis Robert W, van der Meulen Hub G, van der Elst Maarten, Breederveld Roelf S, Tuinebreijer Wim E
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Ziekenhuis Rivierenland, Pres. Kennedylaan 1, 4002 WP Tiel, The Netherlands.
Open Orthop J. 2010 Feb 17;4:71-5. doi: 10.2174/1874325001004020071.
Operative and conservative treatment of wrist fractures might lead to complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) type I.In our multicenter dose response study in which patients with distal radial fractures were randomly allocated to placebo or vitamin C in a daily dose of 200mg, 500mg or 1500mg during 50 days, an operated subgroup was analyzed.48 (of 427) fractures) were operated (11.2%). Twenty-nine patients (60%) were treated with external fixation, 14 patients (29%) with K-wiring according to Kapandji and five patients (10%) with internal plate fixation. The 379 remaining patients were treated with a plaster.In the operated group of patients who received vitamin C no CRPS (0/37) was seen in comparison with one case of CRPS (Kapandji technique) in the operated group who received placebo (1/11 = 9%, p=.23). There was no CRPS after external fixation.In the conservatively treated group 17 cases of CRPS (17/379 = 4.5%) occurred in comparison with one in case of CRPS in the operated group (1/48 = 2.1%, p=.71).External fixation doesn't necessarily lead to a higher incidence of CRPS in distal radial fractures. Vitamin C may also play a role in this. This subgroup analysis in operated distal radial fractures showed no CRPS occurrence with vitamin C prophylaxis.
腕部骨折的手术治疗和保守治疗可能会导致Ⅰ型复杂性区域疼痛综合征(CRPS)。在我们的多中心剂量反应研究中,桡骨远端骨折患者被随机分配至安慰剂组或每日服用200mg、500mg或1500mg维生素C组,为期50天,对其中接受手术的亚组进行了分析。427例骨折中有48例(11.2%)接受了手术治疗。29例患者(60%)采用外固定治疗,14例患者(29%)采用卡潘迪(Kapandji)法克氏针内固定,5例患者(10%)采用钢板内固定。其余379例患者采用石膏固定。在接受维生素C治疗的手术患者组中未观察到CRPS(0/37),而接受安慰剂治疗的手术患者组中有1例CRPS(卡潘迪技术)(1/11 = 9%,p = 0.23)。外固定后未出现CRPS。在保守治疗组中,发生了17例CRPS(17/379 = 4.5%),而手术组中有1例CRPS(1/48 = 2.1%,p = 0.71)。外固定不一定会导致桡骨远端骨折患者CRPS发生率更高。维生素C可能也在其中发挥作用。对接受手术的桡骨远端骨折患者进行的该亚组分析显示,预防性使用维生素C未出现CRPS。