Jean-Pierre Pascal, Hendren Samantha, Fiscella Kevin, Loader Starlene, Rousseau Sally, Schwartzbauer Bonnie, Sanders Mechelle, Carroll Jennifer, Epstein Ronald
Radiation Oncology Department, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY 14642, USA.
J Cancer Educ. 2011 Mar;26(1):111-20. doi: 10.1007/s13187-010-0122-x.
Patient navigation (PN) programs are being widely implemented to reduce disparities in cancer care for racial/ethnic minorities and the poor. However, few systematic studies cogently describe the processes of PN. We qualitatively analyzed 21 transcripts of semistructured exit interviews with three navigators about their experiences with patients who completed a randomized trial of PN. We iteratively discussed codes/categories, reflective remarks, and ways to focus/organize data and developed rules for summarizing data. We followed a three-stage analysis model: reduction, display, and conclusion drawing/verification. We used ATLAS.ti_5.2 for text segmentation, coding, and retrieval. Four categories of factors affecting cancer care outcomes emerged: patients, navigators, navigation processes, and external factors. These categories formed a preliminary conceptual framework describing ways in which PN processes influenced outcomes. Relationships between processes and outcomes were influenced by patient, navigator, and external factors. The process of PN has at its core relationship-building and instrumental assistance. An enhanced understanding of the process of PN derived from our analyses will facilitate improvement in navigators' training and rational design of new PN programs to reduce disparities in cancer-related care.
患者导航(PN)项目正在广泛实施,以减少种族/族裔少数群体和贫困人口在癌症护理方面的差异。然而,很少有系统的研究能令人信服地描述PN的过程。我们对三名导航员就其与完成PN随机试验的患者的经历进行的21份半结构化离职访谈记录进行了定性分析。我们反复讨论代码/类别、反思性评论以及聚焦/组织数据的方法,并制定了总结数据的规则。我们遵循一个三阶段分析模型:简化、呈现和得出结论/验证。我们使用ATLAS.ti_5.2进行文本分割、编码和检索。出现了四类影响癌症护理结果的因素:患者、导航员、导航过程和外部因素。这些类别形成了一个初步的概念框架,描述了PN过程影响结果的方式。过程与结果之间的关系受到患者、导航员和外部因素的影响。PN的过程核心在于建立关系和提供工具性帮助。我们的分析得出的对PN过程的深入理解将有助于改进导航员培训,并合理设计新的PN项目,以减少癌症相关护理方面的差异。