van Alphen S P J
Mondriaan Divisie Ouderen Heerlen/Maastricht.
Tijdschr Gerontol Geriatr. 2010 Apr;41(2):79-86. doi: 10.1007/BF03096186.
This article addresses manifestation, course, diagnosis and treatment of personality disorders in older adults (>60 yrs).
A literature search, using "Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL)", Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (CDSR)", "PsychINFO 2000-present" and "PUBMED", concerning relevant literature from 1980-2009. Keywords were "personality disorder", "elderly", "older adults", "prevalence", "diagnosis" and "treatment". The combinations of these keywords resulted in 32 relevant hits.
Prevalence studies addressing specific personality disorders show that within different subpopulations personality pathology of clusters A and C (odd respectively anxious behaviour) are quite common in older adults whereas cluster B personality disorders (impulsive behaviour) is more prevalent in younger adults. Besides, it appears that the personality questionnaires and interviews used in adult care are not yet validated for older adults in mental health care and nursing homes. Furthermore, there is no convincing reason why psychotherapy variants proven to be effective for adults (<50 yrs) wouldn't be feasible for older adults. Particularly with respect to cognitive (behavioural) therapy and schema therapy, there is some evidence from case studies suggesting that these therapies are well applicable to the elderly.
Prevalence rates appear questionable since the assessment methods applied in the epidemiological studies correspond inadequately to the specific behavioural manifestations of elderly persons with personality pathology. In addition, the number of specific (test)diagnostic tools for older adults are scarce. Currently, there is a lack of empirical data concerning treatment of personality disorders in older adults. However, at this moment several studies are focussed to improve diagnostics and therapy of personality disorders in geriatric psychiatry in the Netherlands and Belgium.
本文探讨老年人(>60岁)人格障碍的表现、病程、诊断及治疗。
使用“Cochrane对照试验中心注册库(CENTRAL)”、“Cochrane系统评价数据库(CDSR)”、“PsychINFO 2000年至今”及“PUBMED”对1980 - 2009年的相关文献进行检索。关键词为“人格障碍”、“老年人”、“年长成人”、“患病率”、“诊断”及“治疗”。这些关键词的组合产生了32条相关记录。
针对特定人格障碍的患病率研究表明,在不同亚群体中,A组和C组的人格病理(分别为古怪和焦虑行为)在老年人中相当常见,而B组人格障碍(冲动行为)在年轻人中更为普遍。此外,成人护理中使用的人格问卷和访谈在精神卫生保健机构及养老院的老年人中尚未得到验证。而且,没有令人信服的理由表明已被证明对成年人(<50岁)有效的心理治疗方法对老年人不可行。特别是关于认知(行为)疗法和图式疗法,有一些案例研究证据表明这些疗法非常适用于老年人。
由于流行病学研究中应用的评估方法与患有个性病理的老年人的特定行为表现不太相符,患病率似乎存在疑问。此外,针对老年人的特定(测试)诊断工具数量稀少。目前,缺乏关于老年人人格障碍治疗的实证数据。然而,此刻荷兰和比利时的几项研究正致力于改善老年精神病学中人格障碍的诊断和治疗。