Tummers J H A, Derksen J L L, van Alphen S P J
Mondriaan Divisie Ouderen Heerlen/Maastricht.
Tijdschr Gerontol Geriatr. 2010 Apr;41(2):87-95. doi: 10.1007/BF03096187.
The instability of personality characteristics and personality disorders during the lifespan is the topic of this literature search. It concerns the effects of this instability for personality assessment in older adults. Five longitudinal studies, based on the Big Five model of Costa & McCrae, support the hypothesis that personality characteristics change during the lifespan. Neuroticism, extraversion and openness decrease with age. In contrast, altruism and conscientiousness increase with age. One longitudinal and three cross-sectional studies of personality pathology indicate age-specific changes in the expression of (mal) adaptive personality characteristics. Besides that, nearly one third of the DSM criteria for Axis II personality disorders are insufficiently applicable to older people, based on a large cross sectional study. Therefore the temporal instability of personality characteristics and the limited validity of the Axis II criteria complicate personality assessment in older adults. Improvements could be found in major standardization studies of personality questionnaires in elderly patients in mental health care and nursing home care. Significant changes in the DSM, such as the development of an age specific and multidimensional approach to personality disorders is also recommended.
人格特质和人格障碍在整个生命周期中的不稳定性是本次文献检索的主题。它涉及这种不稳定性对老年人人格评估的影响。基于科斯塔和麦克雷的大五人格模型的五项纵向研究支持了人格特质在整个生命周期中会发生变化的假设。神经质、外向性和开放性随年龄增长而下降。相比之下,利他主义和尽责性随年龄增长而增加。一项关于人格病理学的纵向研究和三项横断面研究表明,(不良)适应性人格特质的表达存在特定年龄的变化。除此之外,根据一项大型横断面研究,《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》(DSM)中近三分之一的轴II人格障碍标准对老年人的适用性不足。因此,人格特质的时间不稳定性和轴II标准的有限有效性使老年人的人格评估变得复杂。可以在针对精神卫生保健和疗养院护理中的老年患者的人格问卷的主要标准化研究中找到改进方法。还建议对《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》进行重大修订,例如制定针对特定年龄和多维度的人格障碍方法。