Michel Andrew P, Sim Sheina, Powell Thomas H Q, Taylor Michael S, Nosil Patrik, Feder Jeffrey L
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Notre Dame, South Bend, IN 46556-0369, USA.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010 May 25;107(21):9724-9. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1000939107. Epub 2010 May 10.
Speciation with gene flow is expected to generate a heterogeneous pattern of genomic differentiation. The few genes under or physically linked to loci experiencing strong disruptive selection can diverge, whereas gene flow will homogenize the remainder of the genome, resulting in isolated "genomic islands of speciation." We conducted an experimental test of this hypothesis in Rhagoletis pomonella, a model for sympatric ecological speciation. Contrary to expectations, we found widespread divergence throughout the Rhagoletis genome, with the majority of loci displaying host differences, latitudinal clines, associations with adult eclosion time, and within-generation responses to selection in a manipulative overwintering experiment. The latter two results, coupled with linkage disequilibrium analyses, provide experimental evidence that divergence was driven by selection on numerous independent genomic regions rather than by genome-wide genetic drift. "Continents" of multiple differentiated loci, rather than isolated islands of divergence, may characterize even the early stages of speciation. Our results also illustrate how these continents can exhibit variable topography, depending on selection strength, availability of preexisting genetic variation, linkage relationships, and genomic features that reduce recombination. For example, the divergence observed throughout the Rhagoletis genome was clearly accentuated in some regions, such as those harboring chromosomal inversions. These results highlight how the individual genes driving speciation can be embedded within an actively diverging genome.
基因流存在下的物种形成预计会产生基因组分化的异质模式。少数处于经历强烈分裂选择的基因座之下或与之物理连锁的基因会发生分化,而基因流会使基因组的其余部分同质化,从而产生孤立的“物种形成基因组岛”。我们在山楂实蝇(Rhagoletis pomonella)中对这一假说进行了实验检验,山楂实蝇是同域生态物种形成的一个模型。与预期相反,我们发现山楂实蝇基因组中广泛存在分化,大多数基因座表现出宿主差异、纬度渐变群、与成虫羽化时间的关联,以及在一个控制性越冬实验中对选择的代内响应。后两个结果,再加上连锁不平衡分析,提供了实验证据,表明分化是由对众多独立基因组区域的选择驱动的,而非全基因组的遗传漂变。多个分化基因座的“大陆”,而非孤立的分化岛,可能是物种形成早期阶段的特征。我们的结果还说明了这些“大陆”如何根据选择强度、现有遗传变异的可用性、连锁关系以及减少重组的基因组特征而呈现出可变的地形。例如,在山楂实蝇基因组中观察到的分化在某些区域明显加剧,比如那些存在染色体倒位的区域。这些结果突出了驱动物种形成的单个基因是如何嵌入一个正在积极分化的基因组中的。