Craig A R, Calver P
University of Technology, Sydney, Australia.
J Speech Hear Res. 1991 Apr;34(2):279-84. doi: 10.1044/jshr.3402.279.
The present research aimed to investigate perceptions of fluency of persons treated with a fluency shaping technique called smooth speech. Four separate studies were conducted. The first showed that virtually all those treated were satisfied with their fluency following treatment. However, this satisfaction decreased to under half in the long term. The second study showed considerable opportunity in the long term for job promotion and upgrade in occupation for persons successfully completing a smooth-speech program. The third study compared employer perceptions of their employees' speech between a group who had received treatment for stuttering and a nontreatment control. The employers' perceptions of the treatment group were significantly enhanced, whereas no significant change occurred in employers' perceptions for the control group. The last study explored possible determinants of relapse in a population of treated stutterers. Results showed that most had experienced some degree of relapse, but had subsequently recovered. Few believed their relapse was associated with being embarrassed about using smooth speech. The majority believed their relapses were related to feeling pressured to speak faster. Investigating perceptions of fluency following treatment for stuttering seems an important goal for research in order to enhance treatment effectiveness. Directions for further research into this area are discussed.
本研究旨在调查采用一种名为流畅言语塑造技术治疗的患者对流畅性的认知。进行了四项独立研究。第一项研究表明,几乎所有接受治疗的患者在治疗后对自己的流畅性感到满意。然而,从长期来看,这种满意度降至不到一半。第二项研究表明,从长期来看,成功完成流畅言语项目的人有相当大的晋升和职业升级机会。第三项研究比较了接受口吃治疗的一组员工和未接受治疗的对照组员工的雇主对他们言语的认知。雇主对治疗组的认知有显著提高,而对照组雇主的认知没有显著变化。最后一项研究探讨了接受治疗的口吃者群体中复发的可能决定因素。结果表明,大多数人经历了某种程度的复发,但随后恢复了。很少有人认为他们的复发与使用流畅言语感到尴尬有关。大多数人认为他们的复发与说话速度加快带来的压力有关。为了提高治疗效果,调查口吃治疗后的流畅性认知似乎是一个重要的研究目标。讨论了该领域进一步研究的方向。