Meema H E
Department of Radiology, Toronto Hospital, Ontario, Canada.
J Bone Miner Res. 1991 Jan;6(1):9-14. doi: 10.1002/jbmr.5650060104.
Measurements of the combined cortical thickness at the midshafts of the second metacarpal and the proximal radius, as well as their sums, were made from fine-grained radiographs in 107 normal premenopausal and 227 postmenopausal women and in 57 women with at least two spontaneous vertebral compressions. The -2 SD level of the premenopausal women was found to be an excellent vertebral fracture threshold for the radius measuring site and for the sums of metacarpal and radial measurements. Only 2 of 57 (4%) and 3 of 57 (5%), respectively, of values in the vertebral compression group fell at or above this level. At -3 SD a "secondary fracture threshold" was found for the sums in that only 7 of 57 (12%) of values in women with vertebral compressions were above this limit, but -3 SD was less satisfactory for the radius. We conclude that this method discriminates as well between nonfracture and fracture cases as other radiologic methods for measurement of bone mass or density. Because it is less costly it seems better suited for mass screening in selecting postmenopausal women for preventive therapy than the less widely available high-technology methods.
对107名正常绝经前女性、227名绝经后女性以及57名至少有两次自发性椎体压缩的女性,通过细颗粒X线片测量了第二掌骨和桡骨近端中段的皮质厚度总和及其相加值。发现绝经前女性的-2标准差水平是桡骨测量部位以及掌骨和桡骨测量值总和的极佳椎体骨折阈值。椎体压缩组中分别仅有57名中的2名(4%)和57名中的3名(5%)的值处于或高于该水平。在-3标准差时,发现相加值存在一个“二级骨折阈值”,因为椎体压缩女性中仅有57名中的7名(12%)的值高于此限,但-3标准差对桡骨的适用性较差。我们得出结论,该方法在区分非骨折和骨折病例方面与其他测量骨量或骨密度的放射学方法一样有效。由于其成本较低,相比于不太普及的高科技方法,它似乎更适合在筛选绝经后女性进行预防性治疗时进行大规模筛查。