VISN 2 Center of Excellence for Suicide Prevention, US Veterans Administration, Canandaigua, NY 14472, USA.
Suicide Life Threat Behav. 2010 Jun;40(3):193-223. doi: 10.1521/suli.2010.40.3.193.
Durkheim's nineteenth-century analysis of national suicide rates dismissed prior concerns about mortality data fidelity. Over the intervening century, however, evidence documenting various types of error in suicide data has only mounted, and surprising levels of such error continue to be routinely uncovered. Yet the annual suicide rate remains the most widely used population-level suicide metric today. After reviewing the unique sources of bias incurred during stages of suicide data collection and concatenation, we propose a model designed to uniformly estimate error in future studies. A standardized method of error estimation uniformly applied to mortality data could produce data capable of promoting high quality analyses of cross-national research questions.
涂尔干在 19 世纪对各国自杀率的分析摒弃了先前对死亡率数据真实性的关注。然而,在这一个世纪的时间里,记录自杀数据中各种类型错误的证据不断增加,令人惊讶的是,这种错误的水平仍然在继续被常规地发现。尽管如此,自杀率仍然是当今最广泛使用的人群层面自杀指标。在审查了自杀数据收集和拼接过程中产生的独特偏见来源后,我们提出了一个旨在为未来研究统一估计误差的模型。将误差估计的标准化方法统一应用于死亡率数据,可以生成能够促进跨国研究问题高质量分析的数据。