Radu Ciprian-Paul, Chiriac Delia Nona, Vladescu Cristian
National School of Public Health and Health Services Management, 31 Vaselor St., Bucharest 021253, Romania.
Croat Med J. 2010 Jun;51(3):250-8. doi: 10.3325/cmj.2010.51.250.
To evaluate the effects of the change in the diagnosis-related group (DRG) system on patient morbidity and hospital financial performance in the Romanian public health care system.
Three variables were assessed before and after the classification switch in July 2007: clinical outcomes, the case mix index, and hospital budgets, using the database of the National School of Public Health and Health Services Management, which contains data regularly received from hospitals reimbursed through the Romanian DRG scheme (291 in 2009).
The lack of a Romanian system for the calculation of cost-weights imposed the necessity to use an imported system, which was criticized by some clinicians for not accurately reflecting resource consumption in Romanian hospitals. The new DRG classification system allowed a more accurate clinical classification. However, it also exposed a lack of physicians' knowledge on diagnosing and coding procedures, which led to incorrect coding. Consequently, the reported hospital morbidity changed after the DRG switch, reflecting an increase in the national case-mix index of 25% in 2009 (compared with 2007). Since hospitals received the same reimbursement over the first two years after the classification switch, the new DRG system led them sometimes to change patients' diagnoses in order to receive more funding.
Lack of oversight of hospital coding and reporting to the national reimbursement scheme allowed the increase in the case-mix index. The complexity of the new classification system requires more resources (human and financial), better monitoring and evaluation, and improved legislation in order to achieve better hospital resource allocation and more efficient patient care.
评估诊断相关组(DRG)系统的变化对罗马尼亚公共卫生保健系统中患者发病率和医院财务绩效的影响。
利用国家公共卫生与卫生服务管理学院的数据库,评估2007年7月分类转换前后的三个变量:临床结果、病例组合指数和医院预算。该数据库包含通过罗马尼亚DRG计划报销的医院定期上报的数据(2009年有291家医院)。
罗马尼亚缺乏成本权重计算系统,因此有必要使用进口系统,但一些临床医生批评该系统不能准确反映罗马尼亚医院的资源消耗情况。新的DRG分类系统能实现更准确的临床分类。然而,这也暴露出医生在诊断和编码程序方面知识的欠缺,导致编码错误。因此,DRG转换后报告的医院发病率发生了变化,反映出2009年全国病例组合指数比2007年增长了25%。由于在分类转换后的头两年医院获得的报销金额相同,新的DRG系统有时会促使医院改变患者诊断以获得更多资金。
对医院编码缺乏监督以及向国家报销计划的报告工作存在问题,使得病例组合指数得以上升。新分类系统的复杂性需要更多资源(人力和财力)、更好的监测与评估以及完善的立法,以实现更好的医院资源分配和更高效的患者护理。