Bioeng. Dept., Politecnico di Milano, p.zza Leonardo Da Vinci 32, 20133, Milano, Italy.
J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2010 Jun 21;7:28. doi: 10.1186/1743-0003-7-28.
Prader-Willi (PWS) and Down Syndrome (DS) are two genetic disorders characterised by some common clinical and functional features. A quantitative description and comparison of their patterns would contribute to a deeper understanding of the determinants of motor disability in these two syndromes. The aim of this study was to measure gait pattern in PWS and DS in order to provide data for developing evidence-based deficit-specific or common rehabilitation strategies.
19 PWS patients (17.7-40 yr) and 21 DS patients (18-39 yr) were evaluated with an optoelectronic system and force platforms for measuring kinematic and kinetic parameters during walking. The results were compared with those obtained in a group of normal-weight controls (Control Group: CG; 33.4 + 9.6 yr).
The results show that PWS and DS are characterised by different gait strategies. Spatio-temporal parameters indicated a cautious, abnormal gait in both groups, but DS walked with a less stable strategy than PWS. As for kinematics, DS showed a significantly reduced hip and knee flexion, especially at initial contact and ankle range of motion than PWS. DS were characterised by lower ranges of motion (p < 0.05) in all joints than CG and PWS. As for ankle kinetics, both PWS and DS showed a significantly lower push-off during terminal stance than CG, with DS yielding the lowest values. Stiffness at hip and ankle level was increased in DS. PWS showed hip stiffness values close to normal. At ankle level, stiffness was significantly decreased in both groups.
Our data show that DS walk with a less physiological gait pattern than PWS. Based on our results, PWS and DS patients need targeted rehabilitation and exercise prescription. Common to both groups is the aim to improve hypotonia, muscle strength and motor control during gait. In DS, improving pelvis and hip range of motion should represent a major specific goal to optimize gait pattern.
普拉德-威利(PWS)和唐氏综合征(DS)是两种具有一些共同临床和功能特征的遗传疾病。对其模式进行定量描述和比较将有助于更深入地了解这两种综合征中运动障碍的决定因素。本研究的目的是测量 PWS 和 DS 中的步态模式,为制定基于证据的特定缺陷或共同康复策略提供数据。
对 19 名 PWS 患者(17.7-40 岁)和 21 名 DS 患者(18-39 岁)进行了评估,使用光电系统和力平台测量行走过程中的运动学和动力学参数。将结果与正常体重对照组(对照组:CG;33.4+9.6 岁)的结果进行比较。
结果表明,PWS 和 DS 的步态策略不同。时空参数表明两组均存在谨慎、异常的步态,但 DS 的步态策略比 PWS 更不稳定。在运动学方面,DS 的髋关节和膝关节屈曲明显减少,尤其是在初始接触和踝关节活动范围方面,而 PWS 的髋关节和膝关节屈曲明显减少。与 CG 和 PWS 相比,DS 的所有关节活动范围均较小(p<0.05)。在踝关节动力学方面,PWS 和 DS 在后足支撑末期的蹬离明显低于 CG,而 DS 的蹬离最小。髋关节和踝关节水平的刚性在 DS 中增加。PWS 的髋关节刚性值接近正常。在踝关节水平,两组的刚性均明显降低。
我们的数据表明,DS 的步态模式比 PWS 更不生理。基于我们的结果,PWS 和 DS 患者需要有针对性的康复和运动处方。两组共同的目标是改善步态时的低张力、肌肉力量和运动控制。在 DS 中,改善骨盆和髋关节活动范围应是优化步态模式的主要特定目标。