Department of Agronomy, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa 50011, USA.
Plant Physiol. 2010 Sep;154(1):3-12. doi: 10.1104/pp.110.158949. Epub 2010 Jul 23.
Near-isogenic lines (NILs) are valuable genetic resources for many crop species, including soybean (Glycine max). The development of new molecular platforms promises to accelerate the mapping of genetic introgressions in these materials. Here, we compare some existing and emerging methodologies for genetic introgression mapping: single-feature polymorphism analysis, Illumina GoldenGate single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping, and de novo SNP discovery via RNA-Seq analysis of next-generation sequence data. We used these methods to map the introgressed regions in an iron-inefficient soybean NIL and found that the three mapping approaches are complementary when utilized in combination. The comparative RNA-Seq approach offers several additional advantages, including the greatest mapping resolution, marker depth, and de novo marker utility for downstream fine-mapping analysis. We applied the comparative RNA-Seq method to map genetic introgressions in an additional pair of NILs exhibiting differential seed protein content. Furthermore, we attempted to optimize the comparative RNA-Seq approach by assessing the impact of sequence depth, SNP identification methodology, and post hoc analyses on SNP discovery rates. We conclude that the comparative RNA-Seq approach can be optimized with sufficient sampling and by utilizing a post hoc correction accounting for gene density variation that controls for false discoveries.
近等基因系(NILs)是许多作物物种(包括大豆)的宝贵遗传资源。新的分子平台的发展有望加速这些材料中遗传渐渗的图谱绘制。在这里,我们比较了一些现有的和新兴的遗传渐渗图谱绘制方法:单一特征多态性分析、Illumina GoldenGate 单核苷酸多态性(SNP)基因分型,以及通过下一代序列数据的 RNA-Seq 分析进行从头 SNP 发现。我们使用这些方法来映射铁低效大豆 NIL 中的渐渗区域,发现这三种映射方法在联合使用时是互补的。比较 RNA-Seq 方法具有几个额外的优势,包括最高的图谱分辨率、标记深度和从头标记用于下游精细图谱分析的效用。我们应用比较 RNA-Seq 方法来映射在一对表现出不同种子蛋白质含量的 NIL 中的遗传渐渗。此外,我们尝试通过评估序列深度、SNP 识别方法和事后分析对 SNP 发现率的影响来优化比较 RNA-Seq 方法。我们得出的结论是,比较 RNA-Seq 方法可以通过足够的采样和利用事后校正来优化,该校正考虑了基因密度变化,以控制假发现。