Ronquest Rebecca E, Levi Susannah V, Pisoni David B
Speech Research Laboratory, Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Indiana University, 1101 East Tenth Street, Bloomington, IN 47405-1301, USA.
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2010 Aug;72(6):1601-13. doi: 10.3758/APP.72.6.1601.
Our goal in the present study was to examine how observers identify English and Spanish from visual-only displays of speech. First, we replicated the recent findings of Soto-Faraco et al. (2007) with Spanish and English bilingual and monolingual observers using different languages and a different experimental paradigm (identification). We found that prior linguistic experience affected response bias but not sensitivity (Experiment 1). In two additional experiments, we investigated the visual cues that observers use to complete the language-identification task. The results of Experiment 2 indicate that some lexical information is available in the visual signal but that it is limited. Acoustic analyses confirmed that our Spanish and English stimuli differed acoustically with respect to linguistic rhythmic categories. In Experiment 3, we tested whether this rhythmic difference could be used by observers to identify the language when the visual stimuli is temporally reversed, thereby eliminating lexical information but retaining rhythmic differences. The participants performed above chance even in the backward condition, suggesting that the rhythmic differences between the two languages may aid language identification in visual-only speech signals. The results of Experiments 3A and 3B also confirm previous findings that increased stimulus length facilitates language identification. Taken together, the results of these three experiments replicate earlier findings and also show that prior linguistic experience, lexical information, rhythmic structure, and utterance length influence visual-only language identification.
我们在本研究中的目标是探究观察者如何从仅通过视觉呈现的言语中识别英语和西班牙语。首先,我们采用不同的语言和不同的实验范式(识别任务),对说西班牙语和英语的双语及单语观察者重复了索托 - 法拉科等人(2007年)最近的研究结果。我们发现,先前的语言经验会影响反应偏差,但不会影响敏感性(实验1)。在另外两个实验中,我们研究了观察者用于完成语言识别任务的视觉线索。实验2的结果表明,视觉信号中存在一些词汇信息,但很有限。声学分析证实,我们的西班牙语和英语刺激在语言节奏类别方面在声学上存在差异。在实验3中,我们测试了当视觉刺激在时间上反转从而消除词汇信息但保留节奏差异时,观察者是否能够利用这种节奏差异来识别语言。即使在逆向条件下,参与者的表现也高于随机水平,这表明两种语言之间的节奏差异可能有助于在仅通过视觉呈现的言语信号中进行语言识别。实验3A和3B的结果也证实了先前的研究发现,即增加刺激长度有助于语言识别。综合来看,这三个实验的结果重复了早期的研究发现,并且还表明先前的语言经验、词汇信息、节奏结构和话语长度会影响仅通过视觉的语言识别。