Department of Psychology, University of Swansea, Swansea, United Kingdom.
Am J Hum Biol. 2010 Sep-Oct;22(5):604-8. doi: 10.1002/ajhb.21051.
Many studies have reported digit ratio (2D:4D) to be sexually dimorphic, (males lower 2D:4D than females). However, Kratochvíl and Flegr ([2009]: Biol Lett 5:643-646) have suggested that 2D regressed on 4D has an allometric regression line with nonzero Y-intercept that is shared by males and females. Thus, 2D is shorter than expected when 4D is long, and males have lower 2D:4D than females because they have longer fingers. In this study, it is shown that this suggestion may be incorrect because sex differences in slope were not considered. Participants were recruited in an Internet study and had an age range of 12-30 years. The expected sex difference in 2D:4D was found, and the regression of 2D on 4D showed a significant sex difference in slope (males lower than females). A comparison of 10 age groups (12 years, 13 years..., 21-30 years) showed that sexual dimorphism for fingers was age dependent, varying from monomorphic to very dimorphic. Changes in sexual dimorphism of 2D:4D were much less marked, but there was a significant reduction in mean 2D:4D with age. The tendency for slopes of 2D regressed on 4D to be lower in males compared with females was significant in eight age groups. Sex difference in 2D:4D varied across the age groups and was positively related to the magnitude of the difference in female and male slopes. In contrast to the report of Kratochvíl and Flegr, it was found that the regression of 2D on 4D showed sex differences in slope, and such differences gave rise to the sexual dimorphism in 2D:4D.
许多研究报告指出,手指长度比(2D:4D)存在性别二态性,(男性的 2D:4D 比值低于女性)。然而,Kratochvíl 和 Flegr(2009 年):《Biol Lett》5:643-646 认为,2D 与 4D 的回归具有非零 Y 截距的比例回归线,男性和女性都具有该回归线。因此,当 4D 较长时,2D 会比预期的短,而男性的 2D:4D 比值低于女性,因为他们的手指较长。在这项研究中,表明这种说法可能是不正确的,因为没有考虑斜率的性别差异。参与者是通过互联网研究招募的,年龄在 12-30 岁之间。发现了 2D:4D 中的预期性别差异,并且 2D 对 4D 的回归显示斜率存在显著的性别差异(男性低于女性)。对 10 个年龄组(12 岁、13 岁……21-30 岁)的比较表明,手指的性别二态性随年龄变化而变化,从单态到非常二态性不等。2D:4D 的性别二态性变化不太明显,但随着年龄的增长,2D:4D 的平均值显著降低。与女性相比,男性 2D 对 4D 的回归线斜率较低的趋势在八个年龄组中均显著。2D:4D 的性别差异在年龄组之间存在差异,并且与女性和男性斜率差异的大小呈正相关。与 Kratochvíl 和 Flegr 的报告相反,发现 2D 对 4D 的回归显示出斜率的性别差异,这种差异导致了 2D:4D 的性别二态性。