Centre for Studies in Family Medicine, Department of Family Medicine, Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry, The University of Western Ontario, London, ON, Canada.
J Interprof Care. 2011 Jan;25(1):4-10. doi: 10.3109/13561820.2010.497750. Epub 2010 Aug 26.
Increasingly, primary health care teams (PHCTs) depend on the contributions of multiple professionals. However, conflict is inevitable on teams. This article examines PHCTs members' experiences with conflict and responses to conflict. This phenomenological study was conducted using in-depth interviews with 121 participants from 16 PHCTs (10 urban and 6 rural) including a wide range of health care professionals. An iterative analysis process was used to examine the verbatim transcripts. The analysis revealed three main themes: sources of team conflict; barriers to conflict resolution; and strategies for conflict resolution. Sources of team conflict included: role boundary issues; scope of practice; and accountability. Barriers to conflict resolution were: lack of time and workload; people in less powerful positions; lack of recognition or motivation to address conflict; and avoiding confrontation for fear of causing emotional discomfort. Team strategies for conflict resolution included interventions by team leaders and the development of conflict management protocols. Individual strategies included: open and direct communication; a willingness to find solutions; showing respect; and humility. Conflict is inherent in teamwork. However, understanding the potential barriers to conflict resolution can assist PHCTs in developing strategies to resolve conflict in a timely fashion.
越来越多的基层医疗团队(PHCT)依赖于多种专业人员的贡献。然而,团队中冲突是不可避免的。本文考察了 PHCT 成员对冲突的体验以及对冲突的反应。这项现象学研究采用深入访谈的方法,对来自 16 个 PHCT(10 个城市和 6 个农村)的 121 名参与者进行了研究,参与者包括各种医疗保健专业人员。使用迭代分析过程检查逐字记录。分析揭示了三个主要主题:团队冲突的来源;解决冲突的障碍;和解决冲突的策略。团队冲突的来源包括:角色边界问题;实践范围;以及问责制。解决冲突的障碍包括:缺乏时间和工作量;处于弱势地位的人;缺乏解决冲突的认可或动机;以及因害怕引起情绪不适而避免对抗。团队解决冲突的策略包括团队领导的干预和制定冲突管理协议。个人策略包括:开放和直接沟通;愿意寻找解决方案;表示尊重;和谦逊。冲突是团队合作的固有部分。然而,了解解决冲突的潜在障碍可以帮助 PHCT 及时制定解决冲突的策略。