Image Diagnosis Module of the Paraiba Medical School.
Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2010 Jul-Aug;76(4):491-8. doi: 10.1590/S1808-86942010000400014.
Many score methods have been created to measure paranasal sinus abnormalities seen under CT scan. Currently, the Lund-Mackay staging system is widely accepted. However, its results may be affected by the development in children.
To assess the precision and accuracy of a new tomography score, called "opacification-development ratio". It translates the percentage of sinus area that is opaque.
A cross-sectional study was prospectively conducted in patients ranging from 0-18 years of age who underwent CT scan assessment of rhinosinusitis. Two independent radiologists examined each scan twice, using both the Lund system and the ratio herein proposed.
The opacification-development ratio reached substantial intra and inter-examiner agreement, similar to the Lund system (Kappa > 0.60). Considering the Lund system as the gold standard, the most accurate cut-off point was approximately 15 (sensitivity and specificity approach 90%). There was a strong linear correlation between the two methods (r > 90).
opacification-development ratio is precise and correlates with the Lund system. A cut-off point set at 15 could be used to call a test positive.
许多评分方法已经被创建来测量 CT 扫描下观察到的鼻窦异常。目前,Lund-Mackay 分期系统被广泛接受。然而,其结果可能受到儿童发育的影响。
评估一种新的称为“混浊-发育比”的体层摄影评分的精确性和准确性。它将鼻窦区域不透光的百分比转化为分数。
这是一项前瞻性的横断面研究,对 0-18 岁接受鼻窦 CT 扫描评估的患者进行。两名独立的放射科医生使用 Lund 系统和本文提出的比值,对每个扫描进行了两次独立检查。
混浊-发育比达到了较高的内部和外部观察者之间的一致性,类似于 Lund 系统(Kappa > 0.60)。以 Lund 系统为金标准,最准确的截止点约为 15(敏感性和特异性接近 90%)。两种方法之间存在很强的线性相关性(r > 90)。
混浊-发育比精确且与 Lund 系统相关。将 15 作为截止点可用于将测试结果判定为阳性。