Eysenbach Gunther
Centre for Global eHealth Innovation, University Health Network, Toronto, Canada.
Stud Health Technol Inform. 2010;160(Pt 2):1329-33.
Peer-reviewed journals remain important vehicles for knowledge transfer and dissemination in health informatics, yet, their format, processes and business models are changing only slowly. Up to the end of last century, it was common for individual researchers and scientific organizations to leave the business of knowledge transfer to professional publishers, signing away their rights to the works in the process, which in turn impeded wider dissemination. Traditional medical informatics journals are poorly cited and the visibility and uptake of articles beyond the medical informatics community remain limited. In 1999, the Journal of Medical Internet Research (JMIR; http://www.jmir.org) was launched, featuring several innovations including 1) ownership and copyright retained by the authors, 2) electronic-only, "lean" non-for-profit publishing, 3) openly accessible articles with a reversed business model (author pays instead of reader pays), 4) technological innovations such as automatic XML tagging and reference checking, on-the-fly PDF generation from XML, etc., enabling wide distribution in various bibliographic and full-text databases. In the past 10 years, despite limited resources, the journal has emerged as a leading journal in health informatics, and is presently ranked the top journal in the medical informatics and health services research categories by impact factor. The paper summarizes some of the features of the Journal, and uses bibliometric and access data to compare the influence of the Journal on the discipline of medical informatics and other disciplines. While traditional medical informatics journals are primarily cited by other Medical Informatics journals (33%-46% of citations), JMIR papers are to a more often cited by "end-users" (policy, public health, clinical journals), which may be partly attributable to the "open access advantage".
同行评审期刊仍然是健康信息学领域知识转移和传播的重要载体,然而,其形式、流程和商业模式变化缓慢。直到上世纪末,个别研究人员和科研组织通常将知识转移业务交给专业出版商,在此过程中出让作品版权,这反过来又阻碍了更广泛的传播。传统医学信息学期刊的引用率较低,医学信息学领域之外的文章的可见性和被关注度仍然有限。1999年,《医学互联网研究杂志》(JMIR;http://www.jmir.org)创刊,具有多项创新特点,包括:1)作者保留所有权和版权;2)仅以电子形式、“精简”的非营利性出版;3)采用反向商业模式(作者付费而非读者付费)的开放获取文章;4)自动XML标记和参考文献检查、从XML实时生成PDF等技术创新,从而能够在各种书目数据库和全文数据库中广泛传播。在过去10年里,尽管资源有限,该杂志已成为健康信息学领域的领先期刊,目前在医学信息学和卫生服务研究类别中按影响因子排名第一。本文总结了该杂志的一些特点,并利用文献计量学和访问数据来比较该杂志对医学信息学学科和其他学科的影响。虽然传统医学信息学期刊主要被其他医学信息学期刊引用(占引用量的33%-46%),但JMIR的论文更常被“最终用户”(政策、公共卫生、临床期刊)引用,这可能部分归因于“开放获取优势”。