Department of Community Health, Malawi College of Medicine, Blantyre, Malawi.
J Clin Virol. 2010 Dec;49(4):299-302. doi: 10.1016/j.jcv.2010.08.013. Epub 2010 Sep 19.
There is a worldwide need for a pediatric HIV-1 diagnostic test that has a high diagnostic accuracy, is technically simple and cost efficient. The Up24 HIV-1 assay, which requires both the HIV-1 p24 ELISA and the ELAST signal amplification kit, has previously been shown to be a robust tool to diagnose pediatric HIV-1 from dried whole blood spots (DBS) (Cachafeiro et al., JCM 2009;47:459-62(13)). In order to make the assay more accessible to a resource-limited clinical setting, we eliminated the ELAST system, which simplified the Up24 assay, reduced its cost, and tested the accuracy of the modified assay in a rural Malawian hospital.
In this proof of concept study, we tested the ability of a simplified Up24 antigen assay, without ELAST, to detect HIV-1 on DBS obtained via heel prick from 6-week-old Malawian infants.
A case-control study of DBS collected from 113 HIV-infected and 109 HIV-negative infants, using the HIV-1 DNA PCR assay as the reference standard.
The simplified HIV-1 Up24 assay had a sensitivity and specificity of 84% and 98%, respectively. When HIV-1 prevalence is 15%, the positive- and negative-predictive values are 89% and 97%, respectively.
The simplified Up24 assay has a good positive- and a robust negative-predictive values, is easier to perform and has a reduced cost compared to both HIV DNA PCR and Up24 assays. With additional testing, the simplified Up24 assay has the potential to increase global access to pediatric HIV-1 diagnostics.
全球需要一种具有高诊断准确性、技术简单且具有成本效益的儿科 HIV-1 诊断检测方法。Up24 HIV-1 检测法以前曾被证明是一种可靠的工具,可用于从干血斑(DBS)中诊断儿科 HIV-1(Cachafeiro 等人,JCM 2009;47:459-62(13))。为了使该检测法更易于在资源有限的临床环境中使用,我们消除了 ELAST 系统,从而简化了 Up24 检测法,降低了其成本,并在马拉维的一家农村医院测试了改良检测法的准确性。
在本概念验证研究中,我们测试了一种简化的 Up24 抗原检测法(不使用 ELAST)在通过足跟穿刺从 6 周龄马拉维婴儿获得的 DBS 上检测 HIV-1 的能力。
对来自 113 例 HIV 感染婴儿和 109 例 HIV 阴性婴儿的 DBS 进行病例对照研究,以 HIV-1 DNA PCR 检测法作为参考标准。
简化的 HIV-1 Up24 检测法的灵敏度和特异性分别为 84%和 98%。当 HIV-1 流行率为 15%时,阳性和阴性预测值分别为 89%和 97%。
与 HIV DNA PCR 和 Up24 检测法相比,简化的 Up24 检测法具有良好的阳性和稳健的阴性预测值,更易于操作,成本更低。通过进一步的测试,简化的 Up24 检测法有可能增加全球儿科 HIV-1 诊断的可及性。