National Offender Management Service, London.
Sex Abuse. 2010 Dec;22(4):443-70. doi: 10.1177/1079063210384274. Epub 2010 Oct 7.
This study examined the predictive validity of an actuarial risk-assessment tool with convicted sexual offenders in England and Wales. A modified version of the RM2000/s scale and the RM2000 v and c scales (Thornton et al., 2003) were examined for accuracy in predicting proven sexual violent, nonsexual violent, and combined sexual and/or nonsexual violent reoffending in a sample of sexual offenders who had either started a community sentence or been released from prison into the community by March 2007. Rates of proven reoffending were examined at 2 years for the majority of the sample (n = 4,946), and 4 years ( n = 578) for those for whom these data were available. The predictive validity of the RM2000 scales was also explored for different subgroups of sexual offenders to assess the robustness of the tool. Both the modified RM2000/s and the complete v and c scales effectively classified offenders into distinct risk categories that differed significantly in rates of proven sexual and/or nonsexual violent reoffending. Survival analyses on the RM2000/s and v scales (N = 9,284) indicated that the higher risk groups offended more quickly and at a higher rate than lower risk groups. The relative predictive validity of the RM2000/s, v, and c, as calculated using Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC) analyses, were moderate (.68) for RM2000/s and large for both the RM2000/c (.73) and RM2000/v (.80), at the 2-year follow-up. RM2000/s was moderately accurate in predicting relative risk of proven sexual reoffending for a variety of subgroups of sexual offenders.
本研究检验了英国和威尔士性犯罪者使用的一种计算风险评估工具的预测有效性。在一个样本中,对经过修正的 RM2000/s 量表和 RM2000 v 和 c 量表(Thornton 等人,2003)进行了检查,以确定它们在预测已证实的性暴力、非性暴力以及性和/或非性暴力再犯罪方面的准确性,这些性犯罪者要么已经开始社区服刑,要么已经从监狱释放到社区。对大多数样本(n=4946)的 2 年再犯罪率进行了检查,对这些数据可用的样本(n=578)进行了 4 年再犯罪率检查。还为不同的性犯罪者亚组探索了 RM2000 量表的预测有效性,以评估该工具的稳健性。修正后的 RM2000/s 量表和完整的 v 和 c 量表都有效地将罪犯分类为不同的风险类别,这些风险类别在已证实的性和/或非性暴力再犯罪率方面存在显著差异。对 RM2000/s 和 v 量表(N=9284)进行的生存分析表明,高风险组比低风险组更快、更高频率地犯罪。使用接收者操作特征(ROC)分析计算得出的 RM2000/s、v 和 c 的相对预测有效性,在 2 年随访时,RM2000/s 为中等(0.68),RM2000/c 为较大(0.73),RM2000/v 为较大(0.80)。RM2000/s 在预测各种性犯罪者亚组的已证实性再犯罪相对风险方面具有中等准确性。