School of Planning, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario N2L3G1, Canada.
Int J Health Geogr. 2010 Oct 13;9:50. doi: 10.1186/1476-072X-9-50.
Due to the lack of small-scale neighbourhood-level health related indicators, the analysis of social and spatial determinants of health often encounter difficulties in assessing the interrelations of neighbourhood and health. Although secondary data sources are now becoming increasingly available, they usually cannot be directly utilized for analysis in other than the designed study due to sampling issues. This paper aims to develop data handling and spatial interpolation procedures to obtain small area level variables using the Canadian Community Health Surveys (CCHS) data so that meaningful small-scale neighbourhood level health-related indicators can be obtained for community health research and health geographical analysis.
Through the analysis of spatial autocorrelation, cross validation comparison, and modeled effect comparison with census data, kriging is identified as the most appropriate spatial interpolation method for obtaining predicted values of CCHS variables at unknown locations. Based on the spatial structures of CCHS data, kriging parameters are suggested and potential small-area-level health-related indicators are derived. An empirical study is conducted to demonstrate the effective use of derived neighbourhood variables in spatial statistical modeling. Suggestions are also given on the accuracy, reliability and usage of the obtained small area level indicators, as well as further improvements of the interpolation procedures.
CCHS variables are moderately spatially autocorrelated, making kriging a valid method for predicting values at unsampled locations. The derived variables are reliable but somewhat smoother, with smaller variations than the real values. As potential neighbourhood exposures in spatial statistical modeling, these variables are more suitable to be used for exploring potential associations than for testing the significance of these associations, especially for associations that are barely significant. Given the spatial dependency of current health-related risks, the developed procedures are expected to be useful for other similar health surveys to obtain small area level indicators.
由于缺乏小规模邻里层面的健康相关指标,因此在分析健康的社会和空间决定因素时,往往难以评估邻里和健康之间的相互关系。尽管现在二级数据源越来越多,但由于抽样问题,它们通常不能直接用于除设计研究之外的分析。本文旨在开发数据处理和空间插值程序,以使用加拿大社区健康调查(CCHS)数据获得小区域水平变量,以便为社区健康研究和健康地理分析获得有意义的小规模邻里健康相关指标。
通过空间自相关分析、交叉验证比较以及与人口普查数据的模型效果比较,确定克里金插值法是获取未知位置 CCHS 变量预测值的最合适空间插值方法。基于 CCHS 数据的空间结构,提出了克里金参数,并推导出潜在的小区域健康相关指标。进行了一项实证研究,以演示从邻里变量中派生的在空间统计建模中的有效使用。还就获得的小区域水平指标的准确性、可靠性和使用提出了建议,并对插值程序提出了进一步改进。
CCHS 变量具有中度空间自相关性,使得克里金插值法成为预测未采样位置值的有效方法。派生变量是可靠的,但与真实值相比,它们有些平滑,变化较小。作为空间统计建模中的潜在邻里暴露因素,这些变量更适合用于探索潜在关联,而不是用于检验这些关联的显著性,尤其是对于那些几乎没有显著意义的关联。鉴于当前健康相关风险的空间依赖性,预计所开发的程序将有助于其他类似健康调查获得小区域水平指标。