Tilburg University, Department Tranzo, LE Tilburg, The Netherlands.
Health Policy. 2011 Jun;101(1):11-9. doi: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2010.09.011. Epub 2010 Oct 27.
The aim of this study is (1) to gain insight into current multi-sector policy initiatives that contribute to activity-friendly environments for children in four Dutch municipalities, (2) to investigate the role of multi-sector collaboration in multi-sector policy action and (3) to gain insight into critical facilitators and possible challenges for multi-sector policy action aimed at creating activity-friendly environments for children.
A policy analysis was conducted in four Dutch municipalities by means of semi-structured interviews with 25 policy officers from different policy sectors. Interviews were transcribed ad verbatim and analyzed using qualitative data coding software.
Each policy sector carried out policy measures related to (the environmental determinants of) physical activity among children, but most respondents were not aware of the potential effectiveness of their policy measures regarding this topic. In two municipalities structural collaboration between policy sectors was present, but the number of sectors involved was limited. Awareness and support among all policy sectors, a stimulating political environment, and knowing each other and being informed about other sectors' policies were mentioned as facilitators for multi-sector policy action. The main challenge for multi-sector policy action was lack of time and resources.
This study shows that multi-sector policy action aimed at activity-friendly environments could be stimulated by raising awareness and defining problem ownership, enhancing multi-sector collaboration and paying attention to facilitators and challenges.
本研究旨在(1)深入了解有助于四个荷兰城市儿童活动友好环境的当前多部门政策举措;(2)调查多部门合作在多部门政策行动中的作用;(3)深入了解旨在为儿童创造活动友好环境的多部门政策行动的关键促进因素和可能挑战。
通过对来自不同政策部门的 25 名政策官员进行半结构化访谈,在四个荷兰城市进行了政策分析。访谈逐字转录,并使用定性数据分析软件进行分析。
每个政策部门都开展了与儿童身体活动(环境决定因素)相关的政策措施,但大多数受访者并未意识到其政策措施在这一主题上的潜在效果。在两个城市,政策部门之间存在结构性合作,但参与的部门数量有限。提高所有政策部门的认识和支持、营造积极的政治环境、相互了解并了解其他部门的政策,被认为是多部门政策行动的促进因素。多部门政策行动的主要挑战是缺乏时间和资源。
本研究表明,可以通过提高认识和确定问题所有权、加强多部门合作以及关注促进因素和挑战,来促进多部门政策行动,以营造有利于儿童活动的环境。