Motor Control Laboratory, Department of Biomedical Kinesiology, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Tervuursevest 101, Heverlee, Belgium.
Cereb Cortex. 2011 Jun;21(6):1283-94. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhq209. Epub 2010 Oct 28.
Sensory information is critical to correct performance errors online during the execution of complex tasks and can be complemented by augmented feedback (FB). Here, 2 groups of participants acquired a new bimanual coordination pattern under different augmented FB conditions: 1) visual input reflecting coordination between the 2 hands and 2) auditory pacing integrating the timing of both hands into a single temporal structure. Behavioral findings revealed that the visual group became dependent on this augmented FB for performance, whereas the auditory group performed equally well with or without augmented FB by the end of practice. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) results corroborated these behavioral findings: the visual group showed neural activity increases in sensory-specific areas during practice, supporting increased reliance on augmented FB. Conversely, the auditory group showed a neural activity decrease, specifically in areas associated with cognitive/sensory monitoring of motor task performance, supporting the development of a control mode that was less reliant on augmented FB sources. Finally, some remnants of brain activity in sensory-specific areas in the absence of augmented FB were found for the visual group only, illustrating ongoing reliance on these areas. These findings provide the first neural account for the "guidance hypothesis of information FB," extensively supported by behavioral research.
感觉信息对于在执行复杂任务时在线纠正错误至关重要,并且可以通过增强反馈(FB)进行补充。在这里,两组参与者在不同的增强 FB 条件下获得了新的双手协调模式:1)反映双手之间协调的视觉输入,2)将双手的时间整合到单个时间结构中的听觉节奏。行为学研究结果表明,视觉组依赖于这种增强 FB 进行表现,而听觉组在练习结束时无论是否使用增强 FB,表现都一样好。功能磁共振成像(fMRI)结果证实了这些行为学发现:视觉组在练习过程中表现出感官特定区域的神经活动增加,表明对增强 FB 的依赖性增加。相反,听觉组表现出神经活动减少,特别是与运动任务表现的认知/感官监测相关的区域,表明发展了一种对增强 FB 源依赖性较小的控制模式。最后,仅在视觉组中发现了没有增强 FB 时感官特定区域的一些残留脑活动,这表明对这些区域的持续依赖。这些发现为行为研究广泛支持的“信息 FB 指导假说”提供了第一个神经解释。