Department of Family Medicine and Community Health, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA.
Am J Health Promot. 2010 Nov-Dec;25(2):122-5. doi: 10.4278/ajhp.080917-ARB-205.
Vietnamese-Americans (VA) constitute a large minority community that is mostly foreign born with limited English proficiency. This article compares the health content of free print media targeting VA with that of free English-language print media.
Content analysis.
All free print media available at the three largest VA-serving supermarkets in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, were reviewed. Comparison English-language periodicals included free and purchased publications.
We identified and coded 254 health content-containing articles from 22 issues of six periodicals (four free Vietnamese, one free English language, and one purchased English language) collected over a 4-week period.
Chi-square and t-tests for independent samples were used to compare free Vietnamese- and free English-language periodicals. Additional analyses included all English-language periodicals as the comparison group.
Higher proportions of advertisements and "pseudonews" articles (ads formatted like news stories) were found in free Vietnamese- vs. free English-language publications (overt ads, 61% vs. 28%; pseudonews, 18% vs. 0%). Moreover, Vietnamese-language publications did not contain many articles addressing diseases most commonly found in Asian-Americans.
The significant proportion made up by profit-motivated health content in VA print media points to an untapped opportunity to provide evidence-based information about health topics of interest to this community. Future studies should examine secular trends, assess multiple communities, and develop community-based participatory approaches to improving access to quality health information among minorities with limited English proficiency.
越南裔美国人(VA)是一个庞大的少数族裔群体,他们大多出生在国外,英语水平有限。本文比较了针对 VA 的免费印刷媒体与免费英文印刷媒体的健康内容。
内容分析。
在宾夕法尼亚州费城的三家最大的服务于 VA 的超市中,审查了所有可用的免费印刷媒体。比较的英文期刊包括免费和购买的出版物。
我们从六期期刊(四种免费越南语、一种免费英语和一种购买英语)的 22 期中确定并编码了 254 篇包含健康内容的文章,这些期刊是在 4 周的时间内收集的。
使用独立样本的卡方检验和 t 检验比较免费越南语和免费英语期刊。其他分析包括将所有英文期刊作为对照组。
在免费越南语与免费英语出版物中,广告和“伪新闻”文章(新闻故事形式的广告)的比例更高(明显广告,61%比 28%;伪新闻,18%比 0%)。此外,越南语出版物没有包含许多针对亚裔美国人最常见疾病的文章。
VA 印刷媒体中以盈利为动机的健康内容占很大比例,这表明为该社区提供有关健康主题的循证信息存在尚未开发的机会。未来的研究应该检查世俗趋势,评估多个社区,并制定基于社区的参与式方法,以改善英语水平有限的少数族裔获取高质量健康信息的机会。