Butt Mohammad F, Dhar Shabir A, Farooq Munir, Hussain Anwar, Mir Bashir A, Halwai Manzoor A, Zargar Haroon R, Wani Zaid A
Hospital For Bone And Joint Surgery, Srinagar 190005, India. Tel. +91 (94) 19004007. E-mail:
Neurosciences (Riyadh). 2008 Jan;13(1):65-9.
To evaluate the improvement in neurological deficit following late decompression and stabilization of the fractured thoracolumbar spine.
Between January 2001 and August 2004 neurological recovery in 120 thoracolumbar fractures was studied after posterior stabilization at the Hospital for Bone & Joint Surgery, Srinagar, India. There were 88 male and 32 female patients. Fall from a height, usually a tree, was the most common (90%) cause of injury. Seventy-six patients (63%) had neurologic deficit at the time of presentation. The unstable spine was fixed, between 4-18 days after trauma, by posterior short segment instrumentation (Steffee). Neurological recovery for the patients was recorded in the follow-up period. Frankel grade was used to assess the neurological status. The average follow-up period was 25 months (range 8-44 months), and average age was 34 years (18-54).
There were 40 patients (30%) with an incomplete neurological deficit, namely, patients with Frankel grade B, C, and D. Two grades of improvement were found in 8 patients, and one grade improvement in 32 patients with incomplete lesion. Only one third of the patients with complete neuro deficit improved at the final follow-up. The overall result of the surgery for partial lesions was an improvement of at least one Frankel grade in all cases, but no improvement in most of the cases with complete lesion.
This study demonstrates a clear relationship between the level of injury and Frankel grades, translational injuries are associated with a more severe neurologic grade, and surgical intervention appears to improve the neurological outcome, even when the intervention is inadvertently delayed (average 7.9 days).
评估胸腰椎骨折延迟减压及稳定术后神经功能缺损的改善情况。
2001年1月至2004年8月,在印度斯利那加的骨与关节外科医院,对120例胸腰椎骨折患者进行后路稳定术后的神经功能恢复情况进行研究。其中男性88例,女性32例。高处坠落,通常是从树上坠落,是最常见(90%)的受伤原因。76例患者(63%)在就诊时存在神经功能缺损。不稳定脊柱在创伤后4 - 18天通过后路短节段内固定术(Steffee)进行固定。在随访期记录患者的神经功能恢复情况。采用Frankel分级评估神经功能状态。平均随访期为25个月(范围8 - 44个月),平均年龄为34岁(18 - 54岁)。
40例患者(30%)存在不完全神经功能缺损,即Frankel分级为B、C和D级的患者。8例不完全性损伤患者神经功能改善两级,32例患者改善一级。在最终随访时,只有三分之一的完全性神经功能缺损患者有所改善。部分损伤手术的总体结果是所有病例至少改善一个Frankel分级,但大多数完全性损伤病例无改善。
本研究表明损伤程度与Frankel分级之间存在明确关系,平移性损伤与更严重的神经功能分级相关,手术干预似乎能改善神经功能结果,即使干预无意中延迟(平均7.9天)。