Poovathumkadavil A, Leung K F, Al Ghamdi H M, Othman I El Hassan, Meshikhes A-W
Department of Medical Imaging, King Fahad Specialist Hospital, Dammam, Saudi Arabia.
Transplant Proc. 2010 Nov;42(9):3600-5. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2010.07.098.
To determine a formula for estimating the standard liver volume (SLV) in Middle Eastern Arabic adults and to compare it with the 12 standard liver volume (SLV) formulas reported for eastern and western populations.
Liver volume measured using computed tomography (CTLV) was determined in 351 Saudi Arabian adults older than 16 years without liver or body build abnormality. This measurement was correlated with body indices including age, sex, height, weight, body mass index, and body surface area to derive a new formula using multiple-step linear regression analysis. The CTLV was compared with the 12 SLV formulas using the t test, with error % as (SLV - CTLV)/CTLV × 100.
Body weight was the only significant factor that correlated with CTLV, that is, 12.26 × body weight (kg) + 555.65 (R(2) = .37; P = .000). Only the Vauthey formula (1267.28 × body surface area (m(2)) - 794.41) yielded an estimation of SLV that did not differ significantly from CTLV (P = .26), and had the least mean % error of +1% (underestimation by 15.7 mL) and the closest agreement, that is, 62.4% demonstrated less than ±16% error). Other formulas also yielded acceptable agreement with mean % error less than 12%, although the differences from actual measurements were statistically significant. The Chengdu and Chouker formulas were the exceptions, with more than 16% underestimation or overestimation.
Either the formulas derived in the present study and the Vauthey formula could be used to estimate SLV in Middle East Arabic adults. However, the moderate coefficient of determination (R(2) = .37) suggested wide interindividual variation. Caution must be exercised when using these formulas in preoperative planning.
确定中东阿拉伯成年人标准肝脏体积(SLV)的估算公式,并将其与报道的东西方人群的12个标准肝脏体积(SLV)公式进行比较。
在351名年龄大于16岁、无肝脏或体型异常的沙特阿拉伯成年人中,使用计算机断层扫描(CTLV)测量肝脏体积。将该测量值与包括年龄、性别、身高、体重、体重指数和体表面积在内的身体指标进行关联,采用多步线性回归分析得出新公式。使用t检验将CTLV与12个SLV公式进行比较,误差百分比为(SLV - CTLV)/CTLV×100。
体重是与CTLV相关的唯一显著因素,即12.26×体重(kg)+555.65(R² = 0.37;P = 0.000)。只有Vauthey公式(1267.28×体表面积(m²) - 794.41)得出的SLV估算值与CTLV无显著差异(P = 0.26),平均误差百分比最小为+1%(低估15.7 mL)且一致性最高,即62.4%的误差小于±16%。其他公式的平均误差百分比小于12%,与实际测量值的差异虽具有统计学意义,但也显示出可接受的一致性。成都公式和Chouker公式除外,其低估或高估超过16%。
本研究得出的公式和Vauthey公式均可用于估算中东阿拉伯成年人的SLV。然而,中等的决定系数(R² = 0.37)表明个体间差异较大。在术前规划中使用这些公式时必须谨慎。