Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD 21287, USA.
Contraception. 2011 Jan;83(1):34-40. doi: 10.1016/j.contraception.2010.06.018. Epub 2010 Aug 11.
We reviewed our experience with intrauterine device (IUD) placement after surgical abortion up to 20 weeks' gestation.
Women presenting for elective abortion between January 2004 and March 2009 who requested an IUD were included in this retrospective review.
Of 308 women requesting postabortion IUD placement, 221 (72%) planned insertion at the time of abortion (immediate group) and 87 (28%) planned insertion at their postoperative visit (interval group). IUDs were placed in 96% of the immediate group and in 23% of the interval group (212/221 vs. 20/87; p<.0001). Failure to return for placement was the most common reason for noninsertion in the interval group (60/87=69%). Follow-up information was obtained for 56% of patients and was documented a median of 137 days postabortion (range 3-1594 days). There was no difference in complication rates between groups. Expulsion rates were 3% and 0% in the immediate and interval groups, respectively (6/212 vs. 0/20; p=.4). Considering only those with documented follow-up after immediate insertion (119), there was a nonsignificant trend towards increased expulsion with placement after second vs. first trimester abortion (4/54=7% vs. 2/65=2%; p=.3). When analyzing the 172 subjects with documented follow-up, those planning immediate insertion were more likely to have an IUD in situ at the last contact than those planning later insertion (84/124=68% vs. 20/48=42%; p=.002).
Immediate postabortion IUD insertion is safe and effective. Given the low rate of return for interval insertion, immediate placement may be preferable.
我们回顾了在妊娠 20 周以内行人工流产术后放置宫内节育器(IUD)的经验。
本回顾性研究纳入了 2004 年 1 月至 2009 年 3 月期间因选择性流产而就诊且要求放置 IUD 的患者。
在 308 名要求流产后放置 IUD 的患者中,221 名(72%)计划在流产时(即刻组)放置,87 名(28%)计划在术后就诊时放置(间隔组)。即刻组 96%的患者成功放置了 IUD,而间隔组只有 23%(212/221 比 20/87;p<.0001)。间隔组中未返回放置的最常见原因是失访(60/87=69%)。对 56%的患者获得了随访信息,术后中位数随访时间为 137 天(范围 3-1594 天)。两组的并发症发生率无差异。即刻组和间隔组的脱落率分别为 3%和 0%(6/212 比 0/20;p=.4)。仅考虑即刻放置后有记录随访的患者(119 名),第二次妊娠与第一次妊娠流产后放置 IUD 的脱落率呈上升趋势(4/54=7% 比 2/65=2%;p=.3)。在分析了有记录随访的 172 名患者后,即刻放置组在末次随访时 IUD 仍在位的可能性高于间隔放置组(84/124=68% 比 20/48=42%;p=.002)。
流产后即刻放置 IUD 是安全有效的。鉴于间隔放置的患者返回率较低,即刻放置可能更优。