Grundmann R T
Burghausen, Deutschland (vormals: Kreiskliniken Altötting-Burghausen).
Zentralbl Chir. 2010 Dec;135(6):547-55. doi: 10.1055/s-0030-1262624. Epub 2010 Dec 13.
About 160 palliative care units with 1228 beds or 15 beds / 1 million inhabitants were available in German hospitals in the year 2008. Demand analyses consider 35 beds / 1 million inhabitants as necessary. Whether the additional demand could be reduced by a greater use of home- and hospice-based end-of-life care is discussed. For general hospitals the establishment of an acute palliative care unit within a medical (oncology) ward is recommended due to costs, organisation facilities and attitudes of physicians toward referral. The establishment of an acute palliative care unit may be costly for the hospital, nevertheless, outpatient palliative medicine and hospices are a cost-effective health service from a socioeconomic point of view, avoiding unnecessary hospital admissions and freeing up hospital beds by early discharge. An analysis of consultants demonstrates a minor interest of surgeons in specialisation in palliative medicine. However, data suggest that prior experience in palliative care alters the selection of treatment recommendations by surgeons with respect to more supportive or aggressive interventions in patients with advanced cancer. Ethical decision-making regarding therapy and counselling of patients at the end of life and discussing the prognosis with patients and their families require education in palliative medicine. A core curriculum to teach palliative care for surgical residents therefore has been presented.
2008年,德国医院约有160个姑息治疗单元,共1228张床位,即每百万居民拥有15张床位。需求分析认为每百万居民需要35张床位。目前正在探讨是否可以通过更多地利用居家和临终关怀服务来减少额外的需求。由于成本、组织设施以及医生对转诊的态度等因素,建议综合医院在医疗(肿瘤)病房内设立急性姑息治疗单元。对医院来说,设立急性姑息治疗单元可能成本高昂,然而,从社会经济角度来看,门诊姑息治疗和临终关怀机构是具有成本效益的医疗服务,可避免不必要的住院,并通过提前出院腾出医院床位。一项针对会诊医生的分析表明,外科医生对姑息医学专科化的兴趣不大。然而,数据显示,姑息治疗方面的既往经验会改变外科医生对晚期癌症患者治疗建议的选择,使其更倾向于采取更具支持性或积极的干预措施。在临终阶段对患者进行治疗和咨询以及与患者及其家属讨论预后等伦理决策需要接受姑息医学方面的教育。因此,已经提出了一个针对外科住院医师的姑息治疗教学核心课程。