School of Psychology, The University of Exeter, Exeter, EX4 4QG, United Kingdom.
J Appl Psychol. 2011 May;96(3):470-84. doi: 10.1037/a0022133.
The "think manager-think male" (TMTM) association underlies many gender inequalities in the workplace. However, research into the "glass cliff" has demonstrated that the suitability of male and female managers varies as a function of company performance such that in times of poor performance people may "think female" (Ryan & Haslam, 2005, 2007). Three studies examined gender and managerial stereotypes in the context of companies that are doing well or doing badly. Study 1 reproduced TMTM associations for descriptions of managers of successful companies but demonstrated a reversal for managers of unsuccessful companies. Study 2 examined the prescriptive nature of these stereotypes. No TMTM relationship was found for ideal managers of successful companies, but ideal managers of unsuccessful companies were associated with the female stereotype. Study 3 suggested that women may be favored in times of poor performance, not because they are expected to improve the situation, but because they are seen to be good people managers and can take the blame for organizational failure. Together, the studies illustrate the importance of context as a moderator of the TMTM association. Practical and theoretical implications for gender discrimination in the workplace are discussed.
“男性管理者思维”(TMTM)假设是职场性别不平等的根源之一。然而,“玻璃悬崖”的研究表明,男性和女性管理者的适合度会随着公司业绩的变化而变化,即在业绩不佳时,人们可能会“认为女性更适合”(Ryan 和 Haslam,2005,2007)。三项研究考察了在业绩良好和业绩不佳的公司背景下的性别和管理刻板印象。研究 1 再现了成功公司管理者描述中的 TMTM 关联,但对于不成功公司的管理者则出现了反转。研究 2 检验了这些刻板印象的规定性本质。成功公司理想管理者没有发现 TMTM 关系,但不成功公司理想管理者与女性刻板印象有关。研究 3 表明,在业绩不佳时,女性可能会受到青睐,不是因为人们期望她们改善局面,而是因为她们被视为优秀的人事管理者,可以为组织失败承担责任。这些研究共同说明了情境作为 TMTM 关联的调节因素的重要性。讨论了职场性别歧视的实际和理论意义。