Aagaard Jørgen, Müller-Nielsen Klaus
Community Mental Health Centre, Tønder & Augustenborg Hospital, Augustenborg, Denmark.
Nord J Psychiatry. 2011 Oct;65(5):299-305. doi: 10.3109/08039488.2010.544405. Epub 2010 Dec 21.
The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of assertive community treatment (ACT) in the Tønder Region, South Jutland, where the first Danish ACT team was established to treat patients with severe and persistent mental illness (SMI).
The study compares outcome over a 2-year period between recipients of ACT and standard community mental healthcare.
The study included 86 cases and 88 controls. At the time of recruitment, the cases and the controls did not differ significantly in demographic details and eligibility criteria. At the 2-year follow-up, the ACT patients showed a significant reduction in admissions, bed days and day hospital days, and a significant increase in the number of consultations compared with the controls. Adherence to outpatient services was higher in the ACT group. No significant improvements in psychopathology were found after 2 years, but a significant improvement in met needs and fewer unmet needs, indicating better functioning, occurred. Clients' satisfaction with care (Client Satisfaction Questionnaire, CSQ) was significantly higher among ACT patients than among controls.
The treatment of these patients in this ACT service has yielded promising results, suggesting that ACT treatment may be a useful intervention for SMI patients. However, large, rigorous, randomized control trials with ACT are needed in Europe as the existing evidence mainly comes from American studies.
本研究旨在评估丹麦首个积极社区治疗(ACT)团队所在的南日德兰半岛托嫩地区积极社区治疗对重度持续性精神疾病(SMI)患者的治疗效果。
本研究比较了ACT接受者与标准社区精神卫生保健接受者在两年期间的治疗结果。
该研究纳入了86例病例和88例对照。在招募时,病例组和对照组在人口统计学细节和入选标准方面没有显著差异。在2年的随访中,与对照组相比,接受ACT治疗的患者住院次数、住院天数和日间医院就诊天数显著减少,会诊次数显著增加。ACT组对门诊服务的依从性更高。2年后未发现精神病理学有显著改善,但满足需求方面有显著改善,未满足的需求减少,表明功能有所改善。ACT患者对护理的满意度(患者满意度问卷,CSQ)显著高于对照组。
在这项ACT服务中对这些患者的治疗取得了有希望的结果,表明ACT治疗可能是对SMI患者有用的干预措施。然而,欧洲需要开展大规模、严格的ACT随机对照试验,因为现有证据主要来自美国的研究。