School of Public Health, Tropical Medicine and Rehabilitation Sciences, James Cook University, Cairns, Queensland 4870.
Aust N Z J Public Health. 2011 Feb;35(1):47-53. doi: 10.1111/j.1753-6405.2010.00632.x. Epub 2010 Dec 9.
To review available literature addressing the issue of whether smoking status of Indigenous Health Workers (IHWs) impedes provision of health information about smoking tobacco to their communities.
Databases were searched for publications that examined IHWs' smoking status or quit support programs for IHWs. Studies were categorised as reviews and commentaries, intervention studies or descriptive research.
Fourteen studies met inclusion criteria. Overall, the literature suggests that IHWs' smoking status is a barrier. However, the poor quality of most studies weakens the evidence for this conclusion. The issue of IHWs smoking status as a barrier is peripheral to all but two of the studies. Literature cited and reviewed was often not exhaustive and relied on only a few preceding empirical studies. Most studies were unclear about whether IHWs' views were reported as distinct from views of health staff in general.
The recent COAG investment to Tackling Smoking is an important contribution to Closing the Gap in the health of Indigenous Australians. However, there remain potential barriers faced by IHWs that may undermine efforts to reduce Indigenous smoking. Overcoming these barriers and assisting IHWs to quit smoking may provide an opportunity to address high rates of smoking in Indigenous communities. Further research is required with a balance between descriptive research to assess the issue and intervention research to address it.
综述现有文献,探讨原住民卫生工作者(IHWs)的吸烟状况是否阻碍了他们向社区提供有关吸烟的健康信息。
检索数据库中关于 IHWs 吸烟状况或戒烟支持计划的出版物。研究分为综述和评论、干预研究或描述性研究。
符合纳入标准的研究共有 14 项。总体而言,文献表明 IHWs 的吸烟状况是一个障碍。然而,大多数研究的质量较差,削弱了这一结论的证据。除了两项研究外,IHWs 吸烟状况作为障碍的问题只是次要问题。参考文献和综述往往不全面,仅依赖少数先前的实证研究。大多数研究不清楚 IHWs 的观点是否与一般卫生工作人员的观点分开报告。
最近 COAG 投资解决吸烟问题是缩小澳大利亚原住民健康差距的重要贡献。然而,IHWs 仍面临潜在的障碍,这可能会破坏减少原住民吸烟的努力。克服这些障碍并帮助 IHWs 戒烟可能为解决原住民社区的高吸烟率提供机会。需要进一步进行研究,在评估问题的描述性研究和解决问题的干预性研究之间取得平衡。