Sadler David W, Fox Joanna
Centre for Forensic and Legal Medicine, Univeristy of Dundee, UK.
Sci Justice. 2011 Mar;51(1):3-9. doi: 10.1016/j.scijus.2010.10.003. Epub 2010 Nov 10.
Eight male and 8 female subjects underwent serial breath alcohol concentration (BrAC) measurements in the fasting state, following a snack of crisps and following a light meal. BrAC versus time curves were constructed for each subject and the values of peak BrAC (C(max)), theoretical (extrapolated) BrAC at zero time (C(0)), time taken to reach peak (T(max)) and rate of elimination (ß) were recorded directly from the curves. In all subjects values of C(0) extrapolated from the post-meal BrAC-time curves were significantly lower than in the fasting and snack fed states. Since Widmark factor (W.F.) is inversely proportional to C(0), values of WF calculated from extrapolated C(0) after a meal were spuriously high. WF obtained from the fasting BrAC-time curves were usually only slightly higher than those calculated by the Forrest mathematical method. C(max) was highest in fasting subjects (mean 30.5, range 22.5-42μg/100ml) and lowest after a meal (mean 21.4, range 13.5-32μg/100ml). T(max) was shortest after a meal and also remarkably consistent (mean 22, range 17-50min). 'Overshoot' was seen in most fasting subjects within about 40min of consuming alcohol. Elimination of alcohol from breath was slightly lower after a meal (mean 5.4, range 3.9-8.5μg/100ml/h) than after either fasting (mean 6, range 4.7-7.3μg/100ml/h) or a snack (mean 6, range 4.4-8.8μg/100ml/h). The availability of alcohol for absorption (as a percentage of the predicted value) was almost complete after fasting or a snack but after a meal was reduced to only 66% in females and 71% in males. The practical significance of this much reduced peak BrAC after food occurs in relation to forward or back calculations and cases involving post-accident drinking ("the hip flask" defence) as ingestion of a meal before or with alcohol is a common social situation which may complicate BAC estimation in some medico-legal cases.
8名男性和8名女性受试者在空腹状态下、食用薯片零食后以及进食清淡餐后接受了连续的呼气酒精浓度(BrAC)测量。为每个受试者绘制了BrAC随时间变化的曲线,并直接从曲线上记录了峰值BrAC(C(max))、零时刻的理论(外推)BrAC(C(0))、达到峰值所需的时间(T(max))以及消除速率(ß)的值。在所有受试者中,从餐后BrAC - 时间曲线外推得到的C(0)值显著低于空腹和食用零食后的状态。由于维德马克因子(W.F.)与C(0)成反比,因此根据餐后外推的C(0)计算出的WF值偏高。从空腹BrAC - 时间曲线获得的WF通常仅略高于通过福里斯特数学方法计算的值。C(max)在空腹受试者中最高(平均30.5,范围22.5 - 42μg/100ml),在进食后最低(平均21.4,范围13.5 - 32μg/100ml)。T(max)在进食后最短且非常一致(平均22,范围17 - 50分钟)。大多数空腹受试者在饮酒后约40分钟内出现“过冲”现象。呼气中酒精的消除在进食后(平均5.4,范围3.9 - 8.5μg/100ml/小时)略低于空腹后(平均6,范围4.7 - 7.3μg/100ml/小时)或食用零食后(平均6,范围4.4 - 8.8μg/100ml/小时)。空腹或食用零食后酒精的吸收利用率(占预测值的百分比)几乎是完全的,但进食后女性降至仅66%,男性降至71%。进食后BrAC峰值大幅降低的实际意义在于正向或反向计算以及涉及事故后饮酒的案件(“小酒瓶”抗辩),因为在饮酒前或饮酒时进食是常见的社交情况,这可能会在一些法医学案件中使BAC估计变得复杂。