Glandon Douglas M, Muller Jocelyn, Almedom Astier M
Institute for Global Leadership, Tufts University, USA.
Afr Health Sci. 2008 Dec;8 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):S21-7.
Much scholarly and practitioner attention to the impact of Hurricane Katrina on the city of New Orleans, Louisiana has focused on the failures of government disaster prevention and management at all levels, often overlooking the human strength and resourcefulness observed in individuals and groups among the worst-affected communities.
This preliminary study sought to investigate human resilience in the city of New Orleans, State of Louisiana, eighteen months after Hurricane Katrina struck the Mississippi delta region.
The Sense of Coherence scale, short form (SOC-13) was administered to a sample of 41 residents of Lower Ninth Ward and adjacent Wards who had been displaced by Hurricane Katrina but were either living in or visiting their home area during March 2007. Study participants were recruited through the local branch of the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now (ACORN), a nation-wide grassroots organization whose mission is to promote the housing rights of low and moderate-income individuals and families across the USA and in several other countries.
Those who had returned to their homes had significantly higher SOC scores compared to those who were still displaced (p<0.001). Among the latter, those who were members of ACORN scored significantly higher than non-members (p<0.005), and their SOC-13 scores were not significantly different from the scores of study participants who had returned home (including both members and non-members of ACORN).
The findings of this preliminary study concur with previous reports in the literature on the deleterious impact of displacement on individual and collective resilience to disasters. Relevant insight gleaned from the qualitative data gathered during the course of administering the SOC-13 scale compensate for the limitations of the small sample size as they draw attention to the importance of the study participants' sources of social support. Possible avenues for further research are outlined.
众多学者和从业者对卡特里娜飓风对路易斯安那州新奥尔良市的影响的关注,主要集中在各级政府防灾和管理的失败上,常常忽视了在受灾最严重社区的个人和群体中所展现出的人类力量和应变能力。
这项初步研究旨在调查卡特里娜飓风袭击密西西比三角洲地区18个月后,路易斯安那州新奥尔良市居民的心理韧性。
对41名来自下九区及相邻街区的居民进行了简短式连贯感量表(SOC - 13)测试。这些居民因卡特里娜飓风而流离失所,但在2007年3月期间要么居住在其家乡地区,要么正在探访家乡。研究参与者是通过全国性基层组织“现在就社区组织改革协会”(ACORN)的当地分支机构招募的,该组织的使命是在美国和其他几个国家促进低收入和中等收入个人及家庭的住房权利。
与仍流离失所的人相比,那些已返回家园的人SOC得分显著更高(p<0.001)。在后者中,ACORN成员的得分显著高于非成员(p<0.005),并且他们的SOC - 13得分与已返回家园的研究参与者(包括ACORN成员和非成员)的得分没有显著差异。
这项初步研究的结果与文献中先前关于流离失所对个人和集体抗灾能力的有害影响的报告一致。在实施SOC - 13量表过程中收集的定性数据所获得的相关见解,弥补了小样本规模的局限性,因为它们提请人们注意研究参与者社会支持来源的重要性。概述了进一步研究的可能途径。