Research Group Psychosomatic Rehabilitation at the Charité University Medicine Berlin, Germany. michael.linden @ charite.de
Psychother Psychosom. 2011;80(4):199-205. doi: 10.1159/000321580. Epub 2011 Apr 14.
Posttraumatic embitterment disorder (PTED) is a reaction to unjust or humiliating life events, including embitterment and impairment of mood, somatoform complaints, reduction in drive, withdrawal from social contacts, and even suicide and murder suicide. Patients have been shown to be nonresponders to many treatments. This paper gives an outline of cognitive behaviour therapy based on wisdom psychology and reports first data on treatment effects.
In a first pilot study on psychotherapy for PTED, a cohort of 25 PTED inpatients was treated with routine multidimensional cognitive behaviour therapy. A second consecutive cohort of 28 patients was treated with PTED-specific cognitive behaviour therapy, which is based on wisdom psychology (wisdom psychotherapy) and another 29 patients with cognitive behaviour therapy based on wisdom psychology together with additional hedonia strategies (wisdom and hedonia psychotherapy). Treatment integrity was measured with special modules of the Behaviour Therapy Competency Checklist. The outcomes were measured in all 3 groups with the SCL-90 and a global clinical rating of patients and therapists on treatment outcome.
There were significant and clinically meaningful reductions in the SCL score after wisdom therapy, as compared to routine treatment. In clinical ratings by therapists and patients, both specific treatments were judged as more effective than treatment as usual. Additional hedonia strategies did not lead to better treatment effects.
The results of this pilot study suggest that wisdom psychology offers an approach to treat PTED and justify further randomized controlled outcome studies.
创伤后痛苦障碍(PTED)是对不公正或屈辱性生活事件的反应,包括痛苦和情绪受损、躯体形式投诉、动力下降、与社会接触退缩,甚至自杀和谋杀自杀。研究表明,许多治疗方法对患者无效。本文概述了基于智慧心理学的认知行为疗法,并报告了首批治疗效果数据。
在创伤后痛苦障碍心理治疗的首次试点研究中,25 名创伤后痛苦障碍住院患者接受了常规多维认知行为疗法的治疗。第二组连续 28 名患者接受了基于智慧心理学的创伤后痛苦障碍特异性认知行为疗法(智慧心理疗法),另外 29 名患者接受了基于智慧心理学的认知行为疗法,同时辅以额外的快乐策略(智慧和快乐心理疗法)。治疗完整性通过行为疗法能力检查表的特殊模块进行测量。在所有 3 组中,使用 SCL-90 和患者和治疗师对治疗结果的总体临床评分来衡量结果。
与常规治疗相比,智慧治疗后 SCL 评分显著降低,且具有临床意义。在治疗师和患者的临床评估中,两种特定的治疗方法都被认为比常规治疗更有效。额外的快乐策略并没有带来更好的治疗效果。
这项试点研究的结果表明,智慧心理学为治疗创伤后痛苦障碍提供了一种方法,并证明了进一步进行随机对照结局研究的合理性。