Department of Public Health, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Int J Cancer. 2012 May 15;130(10):2438-44. doi: 10.1002/ijc.26248. Epub 2011 Aug 20.
Treatment of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) detectable at screening has helped reduce the incidence of cervical cancer, but has also led to overtreatment. The estimates of overtreatment have often focused on a particular grade of CIN or age group. The aim of this paper was to provide a nationwide population-based estimate of the frequency of CIN treatment per prevented cervical cancer case in a well-screened population. We retrieved the data from the Danish National Population, Patient, Health Insurance, Pathology, and Cancer Registers, and calculated annual age-standardized CIN treatment rates. We estimated the frequency of CIN treatment per prevented cervical cancer case by comparing the cumulative life-time risk of CIN treatment from 1996 onward, with the difference in the cumulative life-time risks of cervical cancer in the prescreening and the screening periods. Since 1996, more than 5,000 CIN treatments were undertaken annually in the population of about 2.2 million women aged 15-84 years, and at present 5.2 CIN treatments are undertaken per 1,000 women aged 20-49. About six women have undergone CIN treatment for each prevented cervical cancer. The frequency of CIN treatment increased after 2004 and at present almost eight women are treated per prevented cervical cancer case. Screening, though effective in reducing the incidence of cervical cancer, leads also to a considerable burden of CIN treatment. Future trends in CIN treatment should be closely monitored.
筛查发现的宫颈上皮内瘤变(CIN)的治疗有助于降低宫颈癌的发病率,但也导致了过度治疗。过度治疗的估计通常集中在特定级别的 CIN 或年龄组。本文的目的是提供基于人群的全国性估计,即在筛查良好的人群中,每预防一例宫颈癌需要治疗的 CIN 频率。我们从丹麦国家人口、患者、健康保险、病理和癌症登记处检索数据,并计算了年度年龄标准化的 CIN 治疗率。我们通过比较从 1996 年开始的 CIN 治疗的终生累积风险,以及在筛查前和筛查期间宫颈癌的终生累积风险差异,来估计每预防一例宫颈癌需要治疗的 CIN 频率。自 1996 年以来,在约 220 万 15-84 岁女性人群中,每年进行超过 5000 次 CIN 治疗,目前每 1000 名 20-49 岁女性中进行 5.2 次 CIN 治疗。每预防一例宫颈癌,就有大约六名女性接受 CIN 治疗。自 2004 年以来,CIN 治疗的频率增加,目前每预防一例宫颈癌病例,就有近 8 名女性接受治疗。尽管筛查在降低宫颈癌发病率方面非常有效,但也导致了大量的 CIN 治疗负担。未来 CIN 治疗的趋势应密切监测。