Guberman Carly, Manassis Katharina
Department of Human Development and Applied Psychology, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto, Ontario.
J Can Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2011 Aug;20(3):186-95.
Previous studies suggest that comorbid anxiety and depressive disorders in youth are associated with more severe symptomatology and family dysfunction than either disorder alone. Our aim was to replicate and extend past findings by expanding the definition of comorbidity to include comorbid subthreshold symptoms (i.e., symptoms fall below the diagnostic criteria cut-off of a disorder).
A clinic-based sample of 193 youth (aged 4-18) and maternal caregivers completed measures assessing the youth's internalizing symptoms and family functioning.
Comorbid youth endorsed more severe anxiety symptoms and family dysfunction than anxiety-only youth. By contrast, comorbid youth did not endorse more severe depression symptoms or family dysfunction compared to youth with depression only. Similar results were found for maternal reports of internalizing symptoms, but maternal reports of family functioning yielded no group differences.
This study replicates past findings that the presence of comorbid depression in anxious youth is associated with severe anxiety and family dysfunction. Our findings also suggest that subthreshold depressive symptoms in anxious youth relate to the severity of symptomatology and family dysfunction reported, but subthreshold anxiety symptoms in depressed youth do not. Longitudinal studies are needed to further clarify the etiology and developmental course of this comorbidity.
先前的研究表明,青少年共病焦虑症和抑郁症比单一疾病伴有更严重的症状学表现和家庭功能障碍。我们的目的是通过扩大共病的定义以纳入共病阈下症状(即症状低于一种疾病的诊断标准临界值)来重复并拓展以往的研究结果。
以诊所为基础,对193名青少年(4至18岁)及其母亲照料者进行抽样,完成评估青少年内化症状和家庭功能的测量。
与仅患焦虑症的青少年相比,共病青少年认可更严重的焦虑症状和家庭功能障碍。相比之下,与仅患抑郁症的青少年相比,共病青少年并未认可更严重的抑郁症状或家庭功能障碍。在内化症状的母亲报告方面发现了类似结果,但在家庭功能的母亲报告方面未发现组间差异。
本研究重复了以往的研究结果,即焦虑青少年中存在共病抑郁症与严重焦虑和家庭功能障碍有关。我们的研究结果还表明,焦虑青少年的阈下抑郁症状与所报告的症状学严重程度和家庭功能障碍有关,但抑郁青少年的阈下焦虑症状并非如此。需要进行纵向研究以进一步阐明这种共病的病因和发展过程。