Catholic University College South-West-Flanders (KATHO), Department HIVB, Wilgenstraat 32, 8800 Roeselare, Belgium.
Vet Microbiol. 2012 Jan 27;154(3-4):363-8. doi: 10.1016/j.vetmic.2011.07.027. Epub 2011 Jul 30.
The performance of chromogenic media for the detection of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) in humans, has been evaluated in numerous studies. However, few comparative studies have been performed for the detection of MRSA in pigs. In this study two different salt concentrations (2.5% or 7.5% NaCl) were evaluated in the enrichment nutrient broth and three selective chromogenic media (chromID MRSA, BrillianceMRSA and MRSASelect) for their ability to detect MRSA in swabs from 29 pigs obtained from three different anatomical sampling sites (anterior nares, skin behind both ears and perineum). ChromID MRSA showed the highest relative sensitivity and specificity after enrichment in 7.5% NaCl, followed by MRSASelect and BrilianceMRSA. For all chromogenic media more MRSA-positive results were obtained for specimens collected from skin behind the ears than for specimens taken from both nares and perineum. The results with regard to the anatomical sampling sites were confirmed in a larger study on three different pig farms involving 60 pigs per farm. Skin behind the ears was the anatomical site with the highest relative sensitivity (91.4%) for MRSA detection compared to perineum and anterior nares, with a relative sensitivity of 76.5% and 75.3%, respectively. An increased relative sensitivity could be achieved when combining two anatomical sites. Sampling of anterior nares and skin behind the ears appeared to be the most sensitive combination with a relative sensitivity of 98.2%. These results show that sampling of only the anterior nares underestimates the real pig MRSA prevalence.
已有大量研究评估了用于检测耐甲氧西林金黄色葡萄球菌(MRSA)的显色培养基在人体中的性能。然而,针对猪源 MRSA 的检测,仅有少数对比研究。本研究评估了两种不同盐浓度(2.5%或 7.5% NaCl)在增菌营养肉汤中的效果,以及三种选择性显色培养基(chromID MRSA、BrillianceMRSA 和 MRSASelect)在检测来自三个不同解剖采样部位(前鼻腔、双耳后皮肤和会阴部)的拭子中 MRSA 的能力。在 7.5% NaCl 增菌后,chromID MRSA 的相对灵敏度和特异性最高,其次是 MRSASelect 和 BrilianceMRSA。对于所有显色培养基,来自双耳后皮肤的标本比来自前鼻腔和会阴部的标本获得更多的 MRSA 阳性结果。在涉及三个不同猪场的 60 头猪的更大规模研究中,证实了关于解剖采样部位的结果。与会阴部和前鼻腔相比,双耳后皮肤是检测 MRSA 的相对灵敏度最高的解剖部位(91.4%),相对灵敏度分别为 76.5%和 75.3%。当组合两个解剖部位时,可以提高相对灵敏度。对前鼻腔和双耳后皮肤进行采样,其相对灵敏度为 98.2%,是最敏感的组合。这些结果表明,仅对前鼻腔进行采样会低估猪源 MRSA 的实际流行率。