Phipps Denham L, Noyce Peter R, Walshe Kieran, Parker Dianne, Ashcroft Darren M
School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Manchester, UK.
Int J Pharm Pract. 2011 Oct;19(5):367-73. doi: 10.1111/j.2042-7174.2011.00119.x. Epub 2011 Jun 14.
OBJECTIVE To establish whether there are any characteristics of pharmacists that predict their likelihood of being subjected to disciplinary action. METHODS The setting was the Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain's Disciplinary Committee. One hundred and seventeen pharmacists, all of whom had been referred to the Disciplinary Committee, were matched with a quota sample of 580 pharmacists who had not been subjected to disciplinary action but that matched the disciplined pharmacists on a set of demographic factors (gender, country of residence, year of registration). Frequency analysis and regression analysis were used to compare the two groups of pharmacists in terms of sector of work, ethnicity, age and country of training. Descriptive statistics were also obtained from the disciplined pharmacists to further explore characteristics of disciplinary cases and those pharmacists who undergo them. KEY FINDINGS While a number of characteristics appeared to increase the likelihood of a pharmacist being referred to the disciplinary committee, only one of these - working in a community pharmacy - was statistically significant. Professional misconduct accounted for a greater proportion of referrals than did clinical malpractice, and approximately one-fifth of pharmacists who went before the Disciplinary Committee had previously been disciplined by the Society. CONCLUSIONS This study provides initial evidence of pharmacist characteristics that are associated with an increased risk of being disciplined, based upon the data currently available. It is recommended that follow-up work is carried out using a more extensive dataset in order to confirm the statistical trends identified here.
目的 确定药剂师是否存在某些特征可预测其受到纪律处分的可能性。方法 研究背景为英国皇家药学会纪律委员会。117名药剂师均被提交至纪律委员会,将其与580名未受到纪律处分但在一系列人口统计学因素(性别、居住国、注册年份)上与受处分药剂师相匹配的配额样本进行匹配。采用频率分析和回归分析,就工作部门、种族、年龄和培训国家等方面对两组药剂师进行比较。还从受处分药剂师处获取描述性统计数据,以进一步探究纪律处分案件及涉事药剂师的特征。主要发现 虽然一些特征似乎会增加药剂师被提交至纪律委员会的可能性,但其中只有一个因素——在社区药房工作——具有统计学意义。与临床失误相比,专业不当行为在提交的案件中占比更大,且提交至纪律委员会的药剂师中约五分之一此前曾受到该学会的纪律处分。结论 基于现有数据,本研究提供了与受纪律处分风险增加相关的药剂师特征的初步证据。建议使用更广泛的数据集开展后续工作,以确认此处确定的统计趋势。