University of Missouri-St. Louis, USA.
Hum Factors. 2011 Aug;53(4):356-70. doi: 10.1177/0018720811411912.
This study contributes to the literature on automation reliance by illuminating the influences of user moods and emotions on reliance on automated systems.
Past work has focused predominantly on cognitive and attitudinal variables, such as perceived machine reliability and trust. However, recent work on human decision making suggests that affective variables (i.e., moods and emotions) are also important. Drawing from the affect infusion model, significant effects of affect are hypothesized. Furthermore, a new affectively laden attitude termed liking is introduced.
Participants watched video clips selected to induce positive or negative moods, then interacted with a fictitious automated system on an X-ray screening task At five time points, important variables were assessed including trust, liking, perceived machine accuracy, user self-perceived accuracy, and reliance.These variables, along with propensity to trust machines and state affect, were integrated in a structural equation model.
Happiness significantly increased trust and liking for the system throughout the task. Liking was the only variable that significantly predicted reliance early in the task. Trust predicted reliance later in the task, whereas perceived machine accuracy and user self-perceived accuracy had no significant direct effects on reliance at any time.
Affective influences on automation reliance are demonstrated, suggesting that this decision-making process may be less rational and more emotional than previously acknowledged.
Liking for a new system may be key to appropriate reliance, particularly early in the task. Positive affect can be easily induced and may be a lever for increasing liking.
本研究通过阐明用户情绪和情感对自动化系统依赖的影响,为自动化依赖文献做出贡献。
过去的工作主要集中在认知和态度变量上,例如感知机器的可靠性和信任。然而,最近关于人类决策的研究表明,情感变量(即情绪)也很重要。根据情感注入模型,假设情感会产生显著影响。此外,引入了一种新的情感化态度,称为喜欢。
参与者观看视频剪辑,以诱导积极或消极的情绪,然后在 X 光筛查任务上与虚构的自动化系统交互。在五个时间点评估重要变量,包括信任、喜欢、感知机器准确性、用户自我感知准确性和依赖程度。这些变量,以及信任机器的倾向和状态情感,被整合到结构方程模型中。
快乐在整个任务中显著增加了对系统的信任和喜欢。喜欢是唯一显著预测任务早期依赖程度的变量。信任在任务后期预测了依赖程度,而感知机器准确性和用户自我感知准确性在任何时候都没有对依赖程度产生显著的直接影响。
证明了情感对自动化依赖的影响,表明这一决策过程可能比以前认识到的更不理性,更情绪化。
对新系统的喜欢可能是适当依赖的关键,特别是在任务早期。积极的情绪很容易被激发,并且可能是增加喜欢程度的一个杠杆。