Heidelberg University Hospital, Spinal Cord Injury Center, Heidelberg, Germany.
J Neurotrauma. 2012 Feb 10;29(3):453-61. doi: 10.1089/neu.2011.2085. Epub 2011 Nov 7.
The International Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury (ISNCSCI), defined by the American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA), and particularly the ASIA Impairment Scale (AIS) are widely used for research and clinical purposes. Although detailed procedures for scaling, scoring, and classification have been defined, misclassifications remain a major problem, especially for cases with missing (i.e., not testable [NT]) data. This work aimed to implement computer-based classification algorithms that included rules for handling NT data. A consistent and structured algorithmic scoring, scaling, and classification scheme, and a computerized application have been developed by redefining logical/mathematical imprecisions. Existing scoring rules are extended for handling NT segments. Design criterion is a pure logical approach so that substitution of non-testability for all valid examination scores leads to concordant results. Nine percent of 5542 datasets from 1594 patients in the database of the European Multicenter Study of Human Spinal Cord Injury (EM-SCI) contained NT segments. After adjusting computational algorithms, the classification accuracy was equivalent between clinical experts and the computational approach and resulted in 84% valid AIS classifications within datasets containing NT. Additionally, the computational method is much more efficient, processing approximately 200,000 classifications/sec. Computational algorithms offer the ability to classify ISNCSCI subscores efficiently and without the risk of human-induced errors. This is of particular clinical relevance, since these scores are used for early predictions of neurological recovery and functional outcome for patients with spinal cord injuries.
国际脊髓损伤神经分类标准(ISNCSCI)由美国脊髓损伤协会(ASIA)定义,特别是 ASIA 损伤量表(AIS),广泛用于研究和临床目的。尽管已经定义了详细的评分、计分和分类程序,但分类错误仍然是一个主要问题,特别是对于缺失(即不可测试[NT])数据的情况。这项工作旨在实施基于计算机的分类算法,包括处理 NT 数据的规则。通过重新定义逻辑/数学不精确性,已经开发出一致和结构化的算法评分、评分和分类方案以及计算机应用程序。现有的评分规则已扩展用于处理 NT 节段。设计标准是纯粹的逻辑方法,因此用所有有效检查分数的不可测试性替代会导致一致的结果。在欧洲多中心人类脊髓损伤研究(EM-SCI)数据库中,来自 1594 名患者的 5542 个数据集的 9%包含 NT 节段。在调整计算算法后,临床专家和计算方法的分类准确性相当,并且在包含 NT 的数据集内有 84%的有效 AIS 分类。此外,计算方法效率更高,大约每秒处理 200,000 个分类。计算算法能够有效地分类 ISNCSCI 子分数,并且没有人为错误的风险。这在临床方面具有特别重要的意义,因为这些分数用于预测脊髓损伤患者的神经恢复和功能结果。