van Tol Erik, Gorter Jan Willem, DeMatteo Carol, Meester-Delver Anke
Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Brain Inj. 2011;25(13-14):1279-87. doi: 10.3109/02699052.2011.613089. Epub 2011 Sep 30.
To review the literature on participation outcomes used in children and adolescents with acquired brain injury (ABI) and to synthesize the available evidence on recovery trajectories in participation after ABI.
This study searched electronic databases (Medline, Cinahl, Embase and PsychInfo) from March 2011 back to the earliest available time (1966) using the following terms with brain injury (brain tumours excluded) and children: social or community or school and outcome assessment or participation. Retrieved articles were rated for methodological quality using Oxford Centre for Evidence Based Medicine criteria (CEBM).
Sixteen articles were included for analysis. The methodological characteristics and quality of these studies varied considerably. Three studies used an explicit participation measure, nine studies featured an implicit participation measure and four used tailored participation measures. There is level 1c evidence that children and adolescents with ABI have participation restrictions at home, at school and in the community 18 months (SD = 14) after discharge.
The available literature indicates that children and adolescents with ABI are at risk for participation restrictions. Research on recovery trajectories in participation after ABI in children is lacking. Longitudinal studies using explicit participation measures and higher quality research methodologies (quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods) are recommended.
回顾有关获得性脑损伤(ABI)儿童和青少年参与结果的文献,并综合现有的关于ABI后参与恢复轨迹的证据。
本研究使用以下术语检索了从2011年3月到最早可用时间(1966年)的电子数据库(Medline、Cinahl、Embase和PsychInfo):脑损伤(不包括脑肿瘤)和儿童,以及社会或社区或学校和结果评估或参与。使用牛津循证医学中心标准(CEBM)对检索到的文章进行方法学质量评分。
纳入16篇文章进行分析。这些研究的方法学特征和质量差异很大。三项研究使用了明确的参与测量方法,九项研究采用了隐含的参与测量方法,四项研究使用了定制的参与测量方法。有1c级证据表明,ABI儿童和青少年在出院后18个月(标准差=14)在家中、学校和社区存在参与限制。
现有文献表明,ABI儿童和青少年存在参与限制的风险。缺乏关于儿童ABI后参与恢复轨迹的研究。建议采用明确的参与测量方法以及更高质量的研究方法(定量、定性和混合方法)进行纵向研究。