Chase-Lansdale P Lindsay, Cherlin Andrew J, Guttmannova Katarina, Fomby Paula, Ribar David C, Coley Rebekah Levine
Northwestern University.
Child Youth Serv Rev. 2011 May;33(5):678-688. doi: 10.1016/j.childyouth.2010.11.016.
We draw upon the 3-wave longitudinal dataset called Welfare Children and Families: A Three-City Study to examine the long-term implications for adolescents and young adults (N=783) of mothers' welfare receipt and labor force participation from 1999 to 2005. In general, changes in mothers' work and welfare patterns were not associated with deterioration or improvement in youth development (ages 16 to 20 years at wave 3). The few significant associations suggested that youth whose mothers increased employment (net of welfare participation) were more likely to show declines in serious behavior problems and delinquency compared to youth whose mothers were unemployed or employed part-time during the study period. Welfare roll exits (controlling for employment experiences) were unrelated to adolescent and young adult outcomes. Mothers' employment transitions were linked to improvements in household income and mothers' self esteem in addition to reductions in financial strain and their own illegal activities. However, these associations did not explain the relation between maternal employment and youths' improved behavior. These results do not support the predictions of either the supporters or the opponents of welfare reform, an outcome we discuss.
我们利用一个名为“福利儿童与家庭:三城市研究”的三波纵向数据集,来考察1999年至2005年母亲领取福利金和劳动力参与情况对青少年及青年(N = 783)的长期影响。总体而言,母亲工作和福利模式的变化与青少年发展(第三波时年龄为16至20岁)的恶化或改善并无关联。少数显著的关联表明,与在研究期间母亲失业或从事兼职工作的青少年相比,母亲就业增加(扣除福利参与因素)的青少年出现严重行为问题和犯罪行为减少的可能性更大。福利登记退出(控制就业经历)与青少年及青年的结果无关。母亲的就业转变除了能减轻经济压力和减少她们自身的非法活动外,还与家庭收入增加以及母亲自尊的提升有关。然而,这些关联并不能解释母亲就业与青少年行为改善之间的关系。这些结果并不支持福利改革支持者或反对者的预测,我们将讨论这一结果。