Gutzmann H, Krüger H, Neumann E M
Max-Bürger-Hospital, Berlin (West), Germany.
Pharmacopsychiatry. 1990 Jun;23 Suppl 4:146-50. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-1014554.
The natural history of classification systems for the organic mental disorders from ICD-8 through ICD-10 and DSM-III is presented. Out of a total of 31 cases the 6 with a main diagnosis of the F0-section of ICD-10 are described and field trial results analysed in terms of classification errors, goodness of fit, difficulty, and interrater-reliability. Specific categories (instead of "collective categories") were used more frequently and fewer classification errors made on the basis of ICD-10 as compared with ICD-9. The authors suggest that an operationalized differentiation of dementia as one of the core categories would further increase the reliability and clinical practicability of this section.
本文介绍了从国际疾病分类第8版(ICD - 8)到国际疾病分类第10版(ICD - 10)以及《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版(DSM - III)中器质性精神障碍分类系统的自然史。在总共31个病例中,描述了主要诊断为ICD - 10中F0章节的6个病例,并从分类错误、拟合优度、难度和评分者间信度方面分析了现场试验结果。与ICD - 9相比,ICD - 10使用特定类别(而非“集合类别”)的频率更高,分类错误更少。作者建议,将痴呆作为核心类别之一进行操作性区分,将进一步提高该章节的可靠性和临床实用性。