Department of Psychology, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC 29208, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2012 Jun;74(11):1833-41. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.08.034. Epub 2011 Sep 24.
By disrupting the routine practices and social structures that support social hierarchy, disasters provide a unique opportunity to observe how gender, race, and class power relations are enacted and reconstituted to shape health inequities. Using a feminist intersectional framework, we examine the dynamic relationships among a government/corporate alliance, front-line disaster recovery workers, and disadvantaged residents in Mississippi Gulf Coast communities in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, which struck in August, 2005. Data were collected between January 2007 and October 2008 through field observations, public document analysis, and in-depth interviews with 32 front-line workers representing 27 non-governmental, nonprofit community-based organizations. Our analysis reveals how power relationships among these groups operated at the macro-level of the political economy as well as in individual lives, increasing health risks among both the disadvantaged and the front-line workers serving and advocating on their behalf. Socially situated as outsiders-within, front-line recovery workers operated in the middle ground between the disadvantaged populations they served and the powerful alliance that controlled access to essential resources. From this location, they both observed and were subject to the processes guiding the allocation of resources and their unequal outcomes. Following a brief period of hope for progressive change, recovery workers became increasingly stressed and fatigued, particularly from lack of communication and coordination, limited resources, insufficient capacity to meet overwhelming demands, and gendered and racialized mechanisms of marginalization and exclusion. The personal and collective health burdens borne by these front-line recovery workers--predominantly women and people of color - exemplify the ways in which the social relations of power and control contribute to health and social inequities.
通过打破支持社会等级制度的日常惯例和社会结构,灾难为观察性别、种族和阶级权力关系如何发挥作用以及如何重新构建以塑造健康不平等现象提供了独特的机会。我们使用女权主义交叉框架,研究了政府/企业联盟、一线灾难恢复工作者与密西西比州墨西哥湾沿岸社区弱势居民之间的动态关系,这些社区在 2005 年 8 月卡特里娜飓风袭击后遭受了影响。数据是通过实地观察、公共文件分析以及对 32 名代表 27 个非政府、非营利社区组织的一线工作人员进行深入访谈,于 2007 年 1 月至 2008 年 10 月期间收集的。我们的分析揭示了这些群体之间的权力关系如何在政治经济的宏观层面以及在个人生活中运作,增加了弱势人群和为他们服务和倡导的一线工作人员的健康风险。作为局内局外人,一线恢复工作人员处于他们所服务的弱势人群和控制获得基本资源的强大联盟之间的中间地带。从这个位置,他们既观察又受到指导资源分配及其不平等结果的过程的影响。在经历了一段对进步变革的短暂希望之后,恢复工作人员变得越来越紧张和疲惫,特别是由于缺乏沟通和协调、资源有限、满足巨大需求的能力不足以及边缘化和排斥的性别和种族化机制。这些一线恢复工作人员——主要是女性和有色人种——承受的个人和集体健康负担体现了权力和控制的社会关系如何导致健康和社会不平等。