Husmann D A, Spence H M
University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, Dallas.
J Urol. 1990 Sep;144(3):607-10. doi: 10.1016/s0022-5347(17)39535-6.
In the final analysis the major question that arises is whether urinary diversion to the intact colon should be performed at all for benign conditions in which a relatively long life expectancy may be anticipated. In answer to this question we believe that if exstrophy is the problem early primary closure with the staged reconstruction should be attempted first. If such efforts are marred by persistent incontinence management with an artificial urinary sphincter should be considered. In individuals with multiple bladder dehiscences after attempts at primary bladder closure, or in an individual with persistent incontinence despite multiple procedures surgical alternates should include diversion by a bowel conduit, continent urinary diversion, a variant of the ureterosigmoidostomy or standard ureterosigmoidostomy. Indeed, despite the appropriate concern regarding the development of tumor in ureterosigmoidostomy, this diversion may still have a major role in the educational process of urology throughout the next decade. Specifically, we must apply the knowledge gained from our clinical and laboratory investigations of ureterosigmoid diversion to the current more popular means of diversion. Of particular concern are the clinical findings of adenocarcinoma in enteric augmentations. This discovery must serve as a warning for the possibility of urocolonic tumors developing within alternative continent urinary diversions within the next 20 to 30 years. Certainly, at least annual evaluations of any diversions are mandatory until we can define accurately the morbidity and mortality arising from our interventional management.
归根结底,出现的主要问题是,对于预期寿命相对较长的良性疾病,是否根本就应进行尿液转流至完整结肠的手术。对于这个问题,我们认为,如果问题是膀胱外翻,应首先尝试早期一期关闭并分期重建。如果这种努力因持续性尿失禁而受阻,则应考虑使用人工尿道括约肌进行处理。对于在尝试一期膀胱关闭后出现多处膀胱裂开的个体,或尽管进行了多次手术仍存在持续性尿失禁的个体,手术替代方案应包括采用肠管造口术、可控性尿液转流、输尿管乙状结肠吻合术的变体或标准输尿管乙状结肠吻合术进行尿液转流。事实上,尽管对输尿管乙状结肠吻合术中肿瘤的发生存在适当的担忧,但这种尿液转流在未来十年泌尿外科的教学过程中可能仍将发挥重要作用。具体而言,我们必须将从输尿管乙状结肠转流的临床和实验室研究中获得的知识应用于当前更流行的转流方法。特别值得关注的是肠道扩大术中腺癌的临床发现。这一发现必须作为一个警示,提醒人们在未来20至30年内,在其他可控性尿液转流中可能会发生尿结肠肿瘤。当然,在我们能够准确界定介入治疗管理所产生的发病率和死亡率之前,至少每年对任何尿液转流进行评估是必不可少的。