Curtin University and Child and Adolescent Health Service, Perth, Western Australia.
J R Soc Med. 2011 Nov;104(11):457-64. doi: 10.1258/jrsm.2011.110015.
Gender bias has been found in medical literature, with more men than women as first or senior authors of papers, despite about half of doctors being women. Nursing is about 90% female, so we aimed to determine if similar biases exist in nursing literature.
Taking the eight non-specialist nursing journals with the highest impact factors for that profession, we counted the numbers of men and women first authors over 30 years.
We used nursing journals from around the world which attract the highest impact factors for nursing publication.
Eight journals qualified for entry, three from the United Kingdom, four from the United States of America, and one from Australia. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Using Chi-square and Fisher exact tests, we determined differences between the numbers of men and women across all the journals, between countries (USA, UK and Australia), changes over the 30 years, and changes within journals over time. RESULTS Despite the small proportion of men in the nursing workforce, up to 30% of first authors were men. UK journals were more likely to have male authors than USA journals, and this increased over time. USA journals had proportions of male first authors consistent with the male proportion of its nursing workforce. CONCLUSIONS In the UK (though not in the USA) gender bias in nursing publishing exists, even though the nursing workforce is strongly feminized. This warrants further research, but is likely to be due to the same reasons for the gender gap in medical publishing; that is, female nurses take time out to have families, and social and family responsibilities prevent them taking opportunities for career progression, whereas men's careers often are not affected in such ways.
医学文献中存在性别偏见,尽管约有一半的医生为女性,但论文的第一作者或资深作者中男性多于女性。护理专业约 90%为女性,因此我们旨在确定护理文献中是否存在类似的偏见。
我们选取了该专业 8 本影响因子最高的非专科护理期刊,统计了 30 多年来男女第一作者的人数。
我们使用了来自世界各地的护理期刊,这些期刊吸引了护理领域最高的影响力。
有 8 本期刊符合入选条件,其中 3 本来自英国,4 本来自美国,1 本来自澳大利亚。
使用卡方检验和 Fisher 确切检验,我们确定了所有期刊、不同国家(美国、英国和澳大利亚)、30 年来以及期刊内部随时间变化的男女作者人数差异。
尽管护理人员中男性比例较小,但高达 30%的第一作者为男性。英国期刊的男性作者比例高于美国期刊,且这一比例随时间增加。美国期刊的男性第一作者比例与护理人员中的男性比例一致。
在英国(而不是在美国),护理出版领域存在性别偏见,尽管护理人员中女性占绝大多数。这需要进一步研究,但可能与医学出版领域性别差距的原因相同;即,女性护士需要花时间照顾家庭,社会和家庭责任使她们无法获得职业发展机会,而男性的职业往往不会受到此类影响。