School of Sociology and Social Policy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK.
Sociol Health Illn. 2012 Feb;34(2):266-82. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9566.2011.01425.x. Epub 2011 Nov 16.
There now exists a considerable body of sociological work examining antenatal screening for fetal abnormalities. A common theme emerging from this literature is that pregnant women report not feeling able to exercise choice freely, experiencing constraints both from medical professionals and their perceived expectations of the sociocultures in which they live. This study adds to existing literature in three ways. Firstly, in contrast to the existing body of interview-based research, the study uses video recordings of actual consultations, in order to capture the interactional processes through which choice and constraints are established, negotiated and contested. Secondly, it explores the next stage in the process of antenatal screening, by focusing on women who are offered invasive diagnostic testing as a result of 'high risk' screening results, and who have been the subject of little research. Thirdly, the study site in Hong Kong provides a particularly interesting location, given limited research on antenatal screening in that part of the world, and Hong Kong's cosmopolitan environment that is reflected in the diversity of client population undergoing antenatal screening. Using conversation analysis we examine how aspects of the clients' diverse socioeconomic backgrounds and circumstances are interactionally managed in this setting, and how this might impact on decision-making.
现在已经有相当数量的社会学工作研究产前筛查胎儿异常。从这些文献中出现的一个共同主题是,孕妇报告说自己无法自由地做出选择,她们不仅受到医疗专业人员的限制,而且还受到她们所生活的社会文化的预期的限制。这项研究在三个方面补充了现有文献。首先,与现有的基于访谈的研究不同,该研究使用实际咨询的视频记录,以捕捉通过互动建立、协商和争议选择和限制的过程。其次,它通过关注因“高风险”筛查结果而被提供侵入性诊断测试的女性,以及那些很少被研究的女性,探索了产前筛查过程的下一个阶段。第三,香港的研究地点提供了一个特别有趣的位置,因为世界上对产前筛查的研究有限,而香港的国际化环境反映在接受产前筛查的客户群体的多样性上。我们使用会话分析来研究客户的不同社会经济背景和情况在这种环境中是如何互动管理的,以及这可能如何影响决策。