Burkart Judith, Kupferberg Aleksandra, Glasauer Stefan, van Schaik Carel
Anthropological Institute and Museum, Zurich, Switzerland.
J Comp Psychol. 2012 May;126(2):129-38. doi: 10.1037/a0026025. Epub 2011 Nov 21.
Intention attribution guides the cognitively most demanding forms of social learning, such as imitation, thereby scaffolding cumulative cultural evolution. However, it is not thought to be necessary for more basic forms of social learning. Here we present evidence that in marmoset monkeys (Callithrix jacchus) even most basic forms of social learning such as enhancement depend on intention attribution. Marmosets perceived the behavior of a conspecific and a conspecific-like robot, but not that of a moving black box, as goal directed. Their subsequent choice behavior was shaped by social facilitation and stimulus enhancement, that is, by very simple forms of social learning, but only when exposed to the conspecific and robot, which they previously had perceived as intentional agents. We discuss the implications of this finding for contemporary debates about social learning, including emulation learning and ghost control studies, the necessity of goal-directed copying for cumulative cultural evolution, and the limits of current classification systems of social learning for the evolution of social and asocial learning.
意图归因引导着社会学习中认知要求最高的形式,如模仿,从而为累积性文化进化搭建支架。然而,人们认为它对于更基本的社会学习形式并非必要。在此,我们提供证据表明,在狨猴(绢毛猴)中,即使是最基本的社会学习形式,如强化,也依赖于意图归因。狨猴将同种个体和类似同种个体的机器人的行为视为有目标导向的,而不认为移动的黑箱的行为是有目标导向的。它们随后的选择行为受到社会促进和刺激增强的影响,也就是说,受到非常简单的社会学习形式的影响,但只有在接触到它们之前视为有意向主体的同种个体和机器人时才会如此。我们讨论了这一发现对当代关于社会学习的辩论的影响,包括模拟学习和幽灵控制研究、累积性文化进化中目标导向模仿的必要性,以及当前社会学习分类系统对社会和非社会学习进化的局限性。